---
id: "workshop:avoiding-the-government-communication-trap"
type: "InnovateUS workshop"
title: "Avoiding the Government Communication Trap"
url: "https://innovate-us.org/avoiding-the-government-communication-trap"
date: "2025-08-12"
duration: "60 minutes"
language: "English"
instructors: ["Jamie Kimes","Terry Rubin"]
recording: "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3oh8_jDe0mM"
transcript: "automatic, from the recording"
source: "InnovateUS (innovate-us.org)"
licence: "CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/), as stated on innovate-us.org"
---

# Avoiding the Government Communication Trap

InnovateUS workshop · 12 August 2025 · 60 minutes

As a government employee, it can be easy to fall into these common communication traps: using too much program, technical, or role-specific jargon, being unclear on what you want your audience to take away, firehosing your audience with lots of information that's impossible to digest. 

This session will help government employees translate complex, jargon-filled communication into clear, engaging, and compelling messages. You'll learn tools to simplify your content, avoid information overload, and communicate better with government stakeholders, such as colleagues, agency leaders, constituents, and elected officials. By the end, you'll be able to break down complex topics and deliver results-driven messages that align with your goals. These skills will boost your ability to drive projects forward and achieve better outcomes.

## Learning goals

- Identify and eliminate communication barriers
- Apply techniques to organize and present complex information in digestible portions that avoid overwhelming your audience
- Develop structured approaches to ensure your communications align with project goals and drive desired outcomes

## Speakers

- **Jamie Kimes**, Founder, The Idea Garden
- **Terry Rubin**, Co-founder and Owner, The Professional Communicators

Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3oh8_jDe0mM

## Transcript

Automatic transcript of the recording: names and terms can be misheard, and the times can be a few seconds off. Each time links to that moment of the video. The transcript alone: https://innovate-us.org/avoiding-the-government-communication-trap.txt (plain text) and https://innovate-us.org/avoiding-the-government-communication-trap.json (every segment with its start and end second).

**Terry Rubin**

[0:02](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=2) I think we're ready to go.

**Jamie Kimes**

[0:03](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=3) I think we are. I mean, everyone has to give us a thumbs up on this beginning slide, right?

**Terry Rubin**

[0:09](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=9) I mean, the creativity of the slide, we knocked it out of the park, right, Terry? I mean, we spent hours on this one. I mean, really, a crazy amount of time doing this.

**Jamie Kimes**

[0:22](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=22) Well, welcome, everyone. We're so excited to be here. Thank you, Agatha. We love working with InnovateUS. Today is a really fun topic about communication, and I want to get it started with a question. So we would love for this to be very interactive, so just jump into the chat. I've got the chat pulled up here, so we'll be able to see. But I would like you to answer, how well do you understand what you do in government? So on a scale of one to five, one being I don't understand it at all, and five being I completely understand it, how well do you understand the nuance, the policy, the jargon of what you do? All right. We have a lot of fours. We have a five. We have some threes. I see that there's people who are fours. You're probably experts, and you're probably just lifetime learners where you're thinking, I always have something to learn. Threes, fours, twos. Interesting, Terry, yes?

**Terry Rubin**

[1:17](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=77) Yeah, very interesting to see the people being honest that, oh, new to the role, I see there as a three, yeah, and Jamie Ponce, maybe it's Ponce, is new to the role, three. So being new to government, definitely that is something to take into account.

**Jamie Kimes**

[1:36](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=96) Yeah. Okay, so now but flip it and imagine someone who is, whether it's a constituent, so a citizen, or someone who's not in your role, how familiar do you think they are with what you do? How much do they understand it? So one being not at all, five being they totally understand, wow, lots of ones, twos, zero, ones, we're all the way on the spectrum, yeah.

**Terry Rubin**

[2:01](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=121) There was a minus five that threw by.

**Jamie Kimes**

[2:04](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=124) But there are minus five. Okay, right. So it's hard, right, to understand government. There's a divide between what you know, as experts, and what the people you are communicating to what they understand about government. So today, we actually want to give you four tools that are going to help you bridge this divide between, you know, and... Can't do this, Jamie, you can't start with the four, we can't tell them that yet. Why not? We have to tell them the truth. What, what is the truth, Terry?

**Terry Rubin**

[2:33](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=153) Tell them, we have to tell them that they're cursed. No, I know it's shocking for you to hear this, but you're all cursed. I know what you're thinking, you work in government, you serve the people, you're helping people make sure the roads are operating, taxes are paid, utilities get done, all of these things are happening in your areas, in your states, in your municipalities, even overseas, that you're doing it, but believe it or not, you're cursed. Well, actually, we're all cursed. And to understand the curse, I need to take you here, to the campus of Stanford University, where a graduate student named Elizabeth Newton discovered the curse. And so she did a social experiment, where she gathered a group of people together, and we're going to call those people the Tappers. The Tappers were assigned to go out to groups of 100 people and tap out well-known songs. Mary had a little lamb, this land is your land, happy birthday. And they had to predict what percent of people in those groups of 100 would pick the song just by them tapping on a tabletop.

[3:43](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=223) And so they all pretty much across the board picked 50%. 50% will get the song right. So off they went on with their pens and the melody and the words in their head, and they went and tapped away. It wasn't even 20%. And it wasn't 50%. It was less than 3% guessed the song correctly. And what Elizabeth Newton discovered is what we know as the curse of knowledge, that the Tappers knew everything. They knew the song, the words in their head. But how they transferred that information prevented the audience from understanding it and from being able to talk about it and name it. And that's the same thing that happens to all of us. You are all experts in your field. Even the people who started new, you have an expertise right now. But how you transfer that information and the way you present it, whether it's written or spoken, can hurt you because it might not get retained or remembered because of the curse of knowledge.

[4:50](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=290) And here's another way to think about it. Think of this big blue circle as everything you know. Everything you know about the education policy you're implementing or the transportation, the new procurement rules that you have to abide by or anything you have to do with revenue sharing in the public-private partnerships. That's the blue circle. And you decide to present on one of those topics. And that's the medium circle in purple. But here's the problem is that because of the curse of knowledge, the small green circle is all that gets retained. And so we want to give you tools and techniques so that the medium circle and the small green circle align more so that more of what you present on, more of what you write about gets retained, gets remembered, and is understood the way you want it to. So here's another way to look at it. So if you were in government and you were talking to a citizen and you said resource realignment occurred to optimize baseline funding streams pursuant to legislative mandates, they probably wouldn't know what you're talking about, right?

[6:04](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=364) They probably would have no idea. And so think about how you would present that to someone who had no idea about what some of these words meant and to think about it in that way. And that's why we want to give you four tools and techniques to help you break that curse and to help you avoid that government talk trap so that people understand you and that people retain what you're talking about.

**Jamie Kimes**

[6:32](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=392) Thank you, Terry. You do such a good job explaining that curse of knowledge. We all have it no matter what program we're working on And it's so true. or what division or department or country that we're in. So the first tool we want to give you is the audience fluency funnel. Any time before you are going into anything that requires communication, whether it's an email, whether it's creating a website, whether it's making some type of public publication, or if you're in a meeting, a public meeting, an internal meeting, any type of a meeting before you go in, I want you to imagine putting your audience through the fluency funnel. And to demonstrate this, we're going to pretend we have two different people. So we have Bernie and we have Gina, and they are both interested in education funding. So we have four questions that we're going to ask about each of these people. All right. How much public sector experience do they have? How much educational funding experience do they have? How much time do they spend thinking about educational funding?

[7:33](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=453) And how much familiarity do they have with all of the words or the jargon around educational funding? So Terry, how about you put Bernie through the audience fluency funnel?

**Terry Rubin**

[7:42](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=462) Sure. So Bernie is a parent who lives in the state, and he wants to know more about how his schools in his area are funded. And so he sets up a meeting with you to hear more about it. And so to go through the funnel, does he have public sector experience? Not really, as a short amount. Does he have any educational funding experience? Does he spend time thinking about education funding? None. Probably a little, but not a lot. And then how familiar is he with the funding jargon? Probably not much at all. Pretty minimal. So we would say he's a beginner in government fluency.

**Jamie Kimes**

[8:24](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=504) And Gina, on the other hand, let's say that she's maybe like a school superintendent or something like that. She's been in public sector for a long time, specifically in education. So you can ask the very same questions about Gina, and she has a long public experience. She has a lot of educational funding experience. Because funding is really important to her goals and objectives, she probably spends a lot of time thinking about educational funding. And she's very familiar with the words or the jargon around education funding. And you can translate this to whatever your program is or to whatever your specific application of this is. But we would say that Gina has an advanced government fluency. If you were to then go into a meeting on the same day with both of these folks, you would probably be able to say something like this to Gina. You could say, education funding operates through various fiscal allocation models, including both formula-based WADA and categorical appropriations to ensure resource distribution aligns with statutory mandates.

[9:29](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=569) And Gina's probably going to be OK with that. She's probably going to get it, and it's going to be fine.

**Terry Rubin**

[9:35](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=575) But you've got to adjust that when it comes to Bernie. So it might be something more like this. Education is funded through different mechanisms established by law. It involves giving school money based on average number of students in the school, formula-based funding, and for special projects, which we call categorical funding. And if you start looking at these two, you can see the differences. You can see that jargon and those words that are used in there. And so paying attention to who your audience is and what their level of expertise is or knowledge is can go such a long way into how you present information and whether it's going to resonate or not.

**Jamie Kimes**

[10:20](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=620) And Dennis, yeah, it does sound like it's written by AI. And this example actually is. And I would like to point out that AI is fantastic for simplifying into simplified language for anything that's written. It's really important to be able to carry that skill into a human-to-human communication. So if you're on video, if you're in an in-person call, on a virtual call, if you're presenting anywhere publicly, you've got to be able to take the skills that AI is really helping us get and translate that into human-to-human communication. And when we think about language and jargon, let's just look at some words that just have to do with education funding. If you put these words on the screen, Terry, the ones I want to really bring up are the really simple ones. So over on the right, or I don't know if it's my right, you see words like procurement or solicitation, even words like grant or statute or title.

[11:20](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=680) These are words that, unless someone is very familiar, they're going to cause questions and confusion. So solicitation, it has different meanings depending on where it's used. Solicitation is very different if you're talking about it in a bar versus talking about it when it comes to educational funding. So we have three really fast just tips for you if you're going into communication with different audiences. Number one, put them through the fluency funnel. And then we use the, is there not a presentation showing?

**Terry Rubin**

[11:49](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=709) There is.

**Jamie Kimes**

[11:50](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=710) There is. Okay, it came in the chat. It says, is there supposed to be a presentation showing? Okay, so it's the three E's. The first one is eliminate. The safest bet, if you do not know who you are talking to, if you don't know who's going to be coming to your website, if you don't know who's coming to your event or you're speaking, eliminate all of the jargon. Just eliminate it and use simple language. If your intent is to educate your audience, then explain the jargon. And we recommend explaining it first. So if you're going to say something like, what's a good example, Terry? My mind's going blank.

**Terry Rubin**

[12:29](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=749) For eliminate?

**Jamie Kimes**

[12:30](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=750) Yeah, for eliminate. No, for explain.

**Terry Rubin**

[12:32](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=752) Oh, for explain.

**Jamie Kimes**

[12:34](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=754) If you're going to do an acronym.

**Terry Rubin**

[12:37](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=757) If you're just going to say what WADA was, think about if you talk about WADA, you have to explain. If you use that acronym in a sentence, you need to probably explain what that means, what that type of funding mechanism is. If you don't.

**Jamie Kimes**

[12:48](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=768) And you'd also want to say the words that it means before you say the acronym. So you'd want to say, let's say it's Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment. which is the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment, Instead of saying CDPHE, you want to do Colorado Public Health and Environment If you use an acronym first, before you say CDPHE. your audience is just going to check out right away. So do the explanation first. Number three, if you know that your audience is very familiar with your topic, then just go ahead and use it. Employ all of the jargon. But that's just really quick. Eliminate, explain or employ, depending on the fluency funnel.

**Terry Rubin**

[13:28](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=808) And so now we want to introduce to you the second tool. And we're going to use these guys. Now, this is a band, an English street band called The Y. And if you're living overseas right now, you probably shouldn't go searching in your local pubs for them. Because if you look at their Instagram, they only existed for about six months. And my theory on it is, is that they spent all of their recording budget for hair care products because they look pretty good. So it's not The Y, the band that we're talking about. It's the idea of why are you talking? Why are you talking? And you might be saying, well, Terry, I have to talk to my leadership team in an hour. Or I have to go do a public town hall with citizens about a change in rules and environmental rules. Or I have to talk to business leaders who want to get permitting sped up.

[14:31](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=871) And that's not why you're talking. Those are the occasions that you're talking. Why you're talking has to do with these. And these are takeaways. And that's our second tool, is we want you to know your takeaways. The fundamental pieces of information that you want your audience to take away from a conversation, from a meeting, from a newsletter, from a website. We want you to think. About what are those foundational takeaways because and we want you to actually write them down before you start typing that email before you go into that meeting before you do that formal presentation and create a powerpoint deck we want you to write down your takeaways because you have to pass a test and the test is what we call the water cooler test and so imagine that you gave a presentation to a group of people about education funding and they met at the water cooler a day later and someone showed up who wasn't at the meeting and said hey what was that education funding meeting about what was that public meeting about and they might say and then response might be uh well they talked about school funding well there you would fail the water cooler test because they're not repeating your takeaways well if you have effective takeaways embedded in your presentation then they might say well they said revenue is changing schools are a priority and funding is fair and now suddenly your takeaways have raised resonated even a day later a week later and they're repeating them back and the details within that are probably going to be there as well because the person might say oh what is funding is fair and now suddenly that ignites

[16:31](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=991) someone and allows them to talk about it more specifically so we want to pass the water cooler test now here's the catch you might say oh great i'll have eight or ten takeaways for this meeting i have coming up but actually that hurts you because you lose your narrative then because there's been scientific studies that show that people only remember four things so you want your takeaways to be four or less if you have five six ten takeaways you are minimizing the chance that people are going to remember what you want them to and thus it creates more communication opportunities miscommunication failed projects things like that start to happen so you want to keep your takeaways to four or less as you're moving forward and we actually want to take a

**Jamie Kimes**

[17:25](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1045) minute for you to practice this so i want you to we have a tool up here on the screen and i'm going to put a link for it in the chat in a second so you can take it and use it back with your teams but right now if you just take a pen or something think of something that you recently communicated whether it was on a website in an email to a group and think about what you communicated and what your takeaways were and just write down what you think the takeaways were we'll give it just what do you think terry 60 seconds yeah let's go we're going to give you a minute or two to do this what were the takeaways that people would have taken from the last time you communicated or a recent time

**Terry Rubin**

[18:10](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1090) and so think about you'll be writing it down on the on the form so

**Jamie Kimes**

[18:36](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1116) give it just a few more seconds here so you can think about it so even if you haven't gotten to where you've actually written them all down you probably at least started thinking about a recent time that you communicated and what the takeaway might have been so this tool that we put in the chat it's designed so that you can put your takeaway there and then in the section i can't see it's not it's not big enough for me to see what it said but it says takeaway one right and then what we want you to do is actually take your takeaway and try to turn it into a heading so a heading is when it's easier to remember right so it terry can you read

**Terry Rubin**

[19:21](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1161) it what it says so funding is allocated so imagine your takeaway was funding is allocated between schools based on a common formula that treats all schools the same but we can turn that into a head a header or a headline that says funding is fair and so now suddenly we have that headline that catches people's attention and then you can give all the details below it you should still have that takeaway but think of ways how to condense it to four or five words so it's really able to be digested and retained and remembered and even repeatable because that can be so important when it comes to taking away information and your main takeaways but takeaways don't always happen with it doesn't it doesn't apply just to spoken communication right jamie yeah it also applies

**Jamie Kimes**

[20:14](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1214) to anything that's written so let's say we went to this website this is a government website um and if i go there i don't really know where to look first so there's a lot of text heavy information here and i'm sure the person putting this together had a lot of knowledge right and knows that everything is important in order for total understanding but as a first person coming and looking at this website and if i were to keep scrolling there's more and more pages of this where it's just dense bullet description bullet description bullet description i don't have any takeaways that i can just look at and say okay i know exactly what's happening with this website i know exactly where to go but now i'd like you to imagine that we applied the takeaway rule to this website what would it look like instead of all of this text heavy information at the beginning we transform it where now we just have four takeaways with arrows where i instantly know where i can go and what's happening on this website so we have available funding sources tools for finding funding common rules where to go to get more information there's my takeaways this works in spoken and this

**Terry Rubin**

[21:22](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1282) works in written so now i want to see if you all pass the water cooler test we want to do a self water cooler test now think of your last communication opportunity whether written or spoken do you think that your audience took away the takeaways that you wanted them to and just put a yes or no in the chat

**Jamie Kimes**

[21:49](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1309) it's yes or no you think they had got some yeses got some nos i'm really tempted to put somebody on the spot and say why are you saying yes but i won't don't worry

**Terry Rubin**

[22:03](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1323) i appreciate people who say no because that's kind of maybe from kathy i appreciate that kathy uh and so even that ambiguity so having those takeaways beforehand and really always referring to them and making and reinforcing them and making sure that you're hitting them can go a long way to making sure your message and those takeaways resonate for sure so we're

**Jamie Kimes**

[22:29](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1349) going to go on to our third tool because we don't have a lot of time here today we could talk about this forever but we're going to go on to the third tool and to introduce this one we're actually going to have a former british prime minister boris johnson in a video so take a look at this go ahead terry and play the video sorry my areas

**Terry Rubin**

[22:57](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1377) should be the comment there we go try one more time let's try it again with safer streets there we go uh with great local schools uh with fantastic uh broadband uh forgive me forgive me forgive me

**Jamie Kimes**

[23:35](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1415) okay okay so just put in the chat what do you think went wrong here angela says she's sweating okay what do you think went wrong i mean obviously he was kind of fumbling through his papers and and things like that but the most important thing too many words well he didn't really seem to have he's lost right tamra he's lost he doesn't know what he wants to say right and that's the biggest thing he just didn't know what he wanted um so terry you can go ahead and introduce the third tool which is knowing how to organize

**Terry Rubin**

[24:09](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1449) yeah we want you to know your organization we we see organization as being one of the biggest tools to breaking that curse into breaking that government letting people know what you're about to talk about and so i want to give you an example we have this here and this is one of our and this is a map and in the map is that's mapped out a road trip and so imagine if i took you took you and throw you in threw you in the car and just took you on this road trip but i didn't say anything about it you'd be wondering one why is this man kidnapping me but two is where am i going am i going for three minutes three days three weeks how long and so i need to give you what i would call a road map and the road map is oh we're going to start up at grand teton national park we're going to work our way down to arches go through meteor crater we're going to end up in phoenix sipping cocktails by the pool in 110 degree heat well now you know where we're going you might be really interested in meteor crater or you might be interested in arches and suddenly you you are an active listener and you're an active participant because i'm giving you a

**Jamie Kimes**

[25:21](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1521) road map and i actually want to show this we're going to show an example here of a road map in action and there's two things that this speaker does really well and then there's one that we would kind of need to work on i want you to watch it and you'll find two things that she does really well so let's now explore how things happen in the budget here i'm going to talk about the key players the state budget process timeline and opportunities for public involvement the key players in the state budget process are okay so what do you think the two things are that she did phenomenally well number one she had a road map right she told us exactly where she was going number two it was really short and it was really easy to digest um the thing that we would want to coach her on is her delivery she's a little bit monotone a little bit hard to listen to but she did a fantastic job on her road map um the rules of road mapping are actually really really simple so number one you've got to do the road map early do it right away and make it in one sentence it's got to be short

**Terry Rubin**

[26:39](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1599) enough to get into one sentence so here it is in action if you see the three you see the three topics that she had and she just put it into this type of one sentence road map which made it really clear what she was going to cover and so if you have a good road map you also need these and these are signposts and think of signposts as an on-ramp and off-ramp within your presentation telling people when you are done with one content area and that you're moving on to the next and yes i know you're surprised by this but we have some rules for signposts and the first rule is every transition every time you transition from one content area to another you need to let your audience know and you're like well how do i let them know good question we want to give you our cap pause and announce system and that is you cap off one content area you take a deliberate pause and you announce the next content area so let's use the california state budget process as an example so we know her road map and now if i was going from the first content area to the second it might look something like this so those are the key players now let's talk about the timeline being that deliberate about it helps re-engage your audience and also keep them engaged so that they are following what you're saying even if you're going through dense information about processes procedures rules regulations doing this helps people stay active listeners now i have a third rule which is probably one of the most important ones which is that it needs to be the same or very similar language as your road map and so it needs to be almost exactly so for example i might say so those are the key players now let's talk about looking at our calendars and

[28:44](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1724) seeing where we have different deadlines along the way now that's the timeline but i use completely different language and you're wondering as an audience member is that the numbers the second content area is he's putting in a different content area is there a sub content area and i'm 30 seconds or a minute down the road and thus i you i've lost you and that's the last thing i want as someone running a meeting or formally presenting you want to make sure that people are lockstep with you and using the same language as your road map in your signposts can help a lot and because this is

**Jamie Kimes**

[29:23](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1763) really really important i'm actually going to put another tool into the chat here so here's another link this is our roadmap sign path signpost tool and there's a part one at the top where it's a place for you to list your major content areas and then the part two in the middle it has you take those content areas and actually put them into a one sentence roadmap and then in part three you can turn that roadmap into your signposts to break up your presentation and again this is completely transferable to written or spoken communication and terry i think we are at our fourth tool so we are going to be

**Terry Rubin**

[30:03](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1803) Yes, we are, and one thing I want to point out is that this same system can be used in extemporaneous speaking in question and answer. You can easily say things like, oh, that's, you know, that's a good question. I have three things I want to talk about. First, this. Second, this. Then you talk about those. I mean, you can, you can do that. One, it does two things. One, if I come up to Kathy Jones and I say, hey, Kathy, I need to tell you this. I need to tell you this. One, if I come up to Kathy Jones and I say, hey, Kathy, I need to tell you two things, and I only tell you one thing, and I start walking away, you're like, whoa, whoa, whoa, what happened to the second thing? You're actively listening to me. So in a question and answer situation, if you say, I want to say two things, I want to give two comments on that question first, and then you give your comment second, people are going to be listening for both of those things. And the second value it brings to you is it allows you to catch up and kind of give you a couple seconds to gather your thoughts. And you might say, well, what if I don't know if I have two or three things? Then just say, there's a few things I'd like to mention. And then you can start numbering them. That's the way to do that. And that's another way of using this roadmap and signpost system to be an effective communicator and to break that curse and to get people listening to you in an active way, speaking extemporaneously.

[31:22](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1882) So now we're going to go on to our fourth tool, and I'm going to do this. We're going to do a little quiz here, and we're going to show you two video clips. This is from the Great American Outdoors Act debate in the U.S. Congress. And I'm going to show you two clips, and I want to know after you listen to both, which one is more persuasive? Which one is it that you are more persuaded by based on these two clips? So the first clip is from former Congressman Gianforte from Montana, and it goes pretty quickly. So get ready for it. Unfortunately, too many of our parks have fallen into disrepair. This bill begins to rebuild and repair our parks. Okay, so that's the first one. Now the second one is from Senator Lamar Alexander of Tennessee. Here it is. Here's what we're talking about. We're talking about leaky roofs. We're talking about access roads with potholes. We're talking about trails that are worn out so you slip and fall down when you go to hike.

[32:30](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1950) We're talking about sewage systems that are broken, shutting down whole campgrounds like the Chilhowee Mountain Campground at the Great Smoky Mountain National Park, which is shut for two years. Five hundred families usually use it every summer and can't go. So which one is it that you were more persuaded by? One or two? And Jamie, you'll have to tell me because I don't have the, I can't see.

**Jamie Kimes**

[32:54](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1974) It's like vast majority is saying two. Two.

**Terry Rubin**

[32:57](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1977) Right, two probably. And so I want to know from your perspective why. Go ahead and put in the chat why you thought.

**Jamie Kimes**

[33:05](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1985) Tangible examples, more visual language specifics. There is one person who said they liked one because it was short and sweet.

**Terry Rubin**

[33:13](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1993) Yeah, and definitely there's something to be said for being concise and to the point.

**Jamie Kimes**

[33:19](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=1999) Connecting it to people's actual lives. I think that's great. Yeah, it makes it real. And that's actually our final tool is know how to make what you're saying real. Make communication real. And go ahead, Terry, you want to talk about the first one?

**Terry Rubin**

[33:36](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=2016) So the first way, so think of making it real on a spectrum. On one side of the spectrum is a really simple way to do it and to make things descriptive and real for people and tangible by what we would say lists. And so thinking about those lists and so, for example. This one is our parks are falling into disrepair, which is what the congressman talked about. And yes, it's a true statement. It's short. It's sweet. But all he would have to do to make it more real, because that's an abstract statement. I don't know how bad it is. Is it just that there's a pothole in a couple places? Do we really need to give 100 billion dollars to this? Or is it bigger? But now, if I put in a list, like, our parks are falling into disrepair because like leaky roofs, trails that are worn out, roads with potholes, broken sewer systems. Now, suddenly you can see it. You can hear it. You can feel it. You can taste it. Even like you can smell it. All of those things start to become and it becomes more real in that.

**Jamie Kimes**

[34:45](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=2085) Not to interrupt you, Terry, but I think it's so applicable to government, because if you say something like, oh, we are prioritizing adoption in our agency, it'd be like we are prioritizing adoption by education for our employees by piloting solutions, making it real and showing the examples of how that works. Yeah, we're prioritizing accessibility by testing all of our websites with screen readers. We're making it very specific.

**Terry Rubin**

[35:20](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=2120) And so we want to show you an example from a government meeting and see how they just added a couple descriptive examples to make something real. The way that we break down the county is using a transect and we go from T1 open space, which would be undeveloped space, like Bells Bend or Beeman Park all the way to T6, which is downtown. So the most developed part of our city. So, right there, she could have just said, we're going to go from T1 open space to T6 downtown and left it at that. But instead she added in those quick examples, Bells Bend, Beeman Park, so that people could picture who are in that area and in this meeting. Oh, yeah, those are open spaces. Those are not and then going all the way to downtown, our most developed area and people start imagining the buildings, the streets, the restaurants, all of that downtown. So it's really important. And you see how effective that is to make it more real rather than just an abstract concept of zoning.

**Jamie Kimes**

[36:22](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=2182) We'll do one more quick example on this one. Oh, yeah. With lists, it's very easy. You just say it's like this and it's like this and it's like this. We want to do one more quick example because I know we're getting to time here on this one. I want you to really pay attention to what this gentleman is saying. So his slide is a little bit distracting because it's very text heavy, but he's doing a great job with his words. So listen to what he's saying. There are also arbitrary distinction on what kinds of businesses can be in each district. And many of these districts are located in similar places, even across the street. So you might find walking along a street that the left side allows movie theaters, but on the right side, they're not allowed. Or you might want to open up a bike sale shop and you can do that today on either side of the street. But if you also want to rent or repair your bicycles, you might have to relocate across the street just to expand your business in the way you want. So if he had just said, he just started out with, there are arbitrary distinctions regarding where businesses can be located. That's 100% true, but it's totally abstract. Instead, he said, there's two bike shops across the street from the other. The one on the left side can sell bikes, but zoning prevents them from renting bikes.

[37:42](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=2262) And the bike store on the right, however, can both sell and rent bikes. And that's how arbitrary our zoning is. So he just made it very, very real by giving these examples. And I'd love for you as your homework to take the takeaways that you started writing down and figure out how to add lists or examples to make those no longer abstract, but to make them very real for your audience.

**Terry Rubin**

[38:10](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=2290) And that's four tools to help you break the curse and also to avoid that government talk trap. Think about knowing your audience, using that audience fluency funnel, putting people through it. There was a good question that came up in the chat. What if you have a mixed audience? And you want to kind of go to your common denominator, but still throw in expertise language at times so that people who are experts are feeling like, oh, you're talking to me as well. So you have to balance that, but you don't want to alienate people who have no knowledge at all. So you have to apply to them, but you also need to address some terms, some examples that will give people who are experts in that field or knowledgeable to make sure that they feel like, oh, this is valuable to me as well. And we can talk about that more in the Q&A session. The second one is know your takeaways. Write down those takeaways. They should be four or less. Don't have more than that. And really make sure that you use those as a guide as you're putting together either written communication or spoken communication.

[39:23](https://youtu.be/3oh8_jDe0mM?t=2363) And then the third is know how to organize. That roadmap and signpost system, you can use it in a formal presentation, you can use it in written communication, and you can use it in extemporaneous speaking. And then finally, know how to make it real. Think about that spectrum. Simple lists or an example or a story or a hypothetical that brings that policy, that brings that process, that brings that procedure to life and really helps people understand what you're talking about. That is a secret sauce to breaking the curse, is by making things real and tangible so it's not just abstract policy and rules and procedures, that it's real and tangible.

* * *

Original page: https://innovate-us.org/avoiding-the-government-communication-trap · Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/), as stated on innovate-us.org
