---
id: "workshop:how-and-why-to-form-new-collaborative-relationships-to-tackle-civic-challenges"
type: "InnovateUS workshop"
title: "How (and Why!) to Form New Collaborative Relationships to Tackle Civic Challenges"
url: "https://innovate-us.org/how-and-why-to-form-new-collaborative-relationships-to-tackle-civic-challenges"
date: "2024-09-05"
duration: "90 minutes"
language: "English"
instructors: ["Adam Seth Levine"]
recording: "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pWH34ChkOck"
transcript: "automatic, from the recording"
source: "InnovateUS (innovate-us.org)"
licence: "CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/), as stated on innovate-us.org"
---

# How (and Why!) to Form New Collaborative Relationships to Tackle Civic Challenges

InnovateUS workshop · 5 September 2024 · 90 minutes

Join us for a 90-minute virtual workshop with Adam Levine, Professor of Health Policy and Management in the Bloomberg School of Public Health at Johns Hopkins, on the collaborative relationships needed to tackle civic challenges. New forms of collaboration don’t often happen on their own. Why not, and what can we do about it? During this workshop, participants will learn about the fundamentals of the science of collaboration, which helps explain why this "unmet desire” arises. Participants will learn about tools that are useful for surfacing unmet collaborative desire and then meeting it. Participants will have plenty of time to try the tools out themselves, in order to reflect upon the kinds of collaborative relationships with diverse thinkers that would help advance their own work. Participants will walk away from the workshop with an action plan for creating new collaborative relationships for their own work.

## Learning goals

- Learn about collaborative relationships needed to tackle civic challenges
- Learn about the fundamentals of the science of collaboration
- Learn about tools that are useful for surfacing and meeting collaboration interests and needs
- Try the tools out and reflect upon the kinds of collaborative relationships with diverse thinkers that would help advance your own work
- Walk away from the workshop with an action plan for creating new collaborative relationships for your own work
- This workshop content is based on research and actionable tools discussed Levine's new book, *[Collaborate Now! How Expertise Becomes Useful in Civic Life](https://www.amazon.com/Collaborate-Now-Expertise-Becomes-Useful/dp/100941187X/ref=tmm_pap_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&dib_tag=se&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.E8vWuqdolFWNh0iSfAytRg.EaRf6W3tmV0t7rztt1CdcVekC-FeVjt9QeqzAbUnkm0&qid=1721679256&sr=8-1)*

## Speakers

- **Adam Seth Levine**, SNF Agora Professor of Health Policy and Management, Bloomberg School of Public Health at Johns Hopkins University

Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pWH34ChkOck

## Transcript

Automatic transcript of the recording: names and terms can be misheard, and the times can be a few seconds off. Each time links to that moment of the video. The transcript alone: https://innovate-us.org/how-and-why-to-form-new-collaborative-relationships-to-tackle-civic-challenges.txt (plain text) and https://innovate-us.org/how-and-why-to-form-new-collaborative-relationships-to-tackle-civic-challenges.json (every segment with its start and end second).

**Unknown speaker**

[0:01](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=1) I'll turn it over to you, Adam. Welcome.

**Adam Seth Levine**

[0:07](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=7) All right, fantastic. Hi, everybody. It's really great to be here, and I really appreciate all of you joining us on this session this afternoon, or this morning, depending on where you are, or this evening, depending on where you are. So, as Hannah mentioned, I'm Adam Levine, and I'm a professor at Johns Hopkins, and I also run this nonprofit called Research for Impact. And it is really great to see you, and this is a workshop that I often lead that is sort of related to the book that Hannah mentioned, called Collaborate Now. And it really is about sort of how to sort of form new collaborative relationships, and why they often don't sort of form on their own, and kind of what we can do about it. And I'm going to start by sort of telling a story. And I do have slides, and I'm going to share my screen shortly. But I'm going to start by telling a story, just to kind of like illustrate sort of how I even got into some of this work, and why I think it's sort of interesting and useful. And then there's going to be a slight interactive portion basically in the middle. I'm going to actually ask all of you some questions to think about, and then invite hopefully some folks to respond.

[1:12](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=72) And Hannah has already warned me that like it's a little bit hard, you know, with this size of a group, and like via Zoom to sort of do this kind of in real time. But we'll do our best, and, you know, see how that goes. And then I'm going to kind of come back to sort of doing more kind of standard presentation style stuff. And then we'll have time for Q&A at the end. And so anyways, that's kind of, so it's like a little bit of me, then you, then more of me, and then you. And so hopefully, you know, we'll break it up, and we have until 3.30 Eastern time. And I really do encourage you to ask questions. I'm going to be sharing my screen, and so unfortunately I actually won't see the questions. But I know that like Hannah sort of is on it. And so I really sort of, you know, encourage folks to share questions. And at the very least, we'll talk about them at the end. If not, you know, we'll, you know, she'll just sort of stop me in the middle. And with that, I'm going to share my screen and talk about some cool stuff here.

[2:20](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=140) All right. So that's me. And I want to start by sort of sharing a story. And so this story, Research for Impact 1.0. And there is a 2.0. In fact, the 2.0 is the part that exists right now. But Research for Impact 1.0 was formed back in 2017. It was me and I have two amazing co-founders, and we're all sort of trained political scientists. And the reason why Research for Impact was formed was that all of us individually had had a lot of people who are sort of coming to us and saying, you know, like we would, and researchers who are coming to us and practitioners who are coming to us and saying, you know, we would love to engage in more sort of collaborative relationships cross sectorally. But like, you know, like we don't really know how to get started. And, you know, people would sort of see me like, for example, give like I was working with a number of different kind of nonprofit organizations and, you know, they would see me sort of giving talks and at conferences and things like that.

[3:22](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=202) And I would often like get this question of sort of like, you know, where do you find these organizations? Like, how do you get them to talk to you and whatnot? And like, and I would get similar kinds of questions with policymakers, like how do you get policymakers to sort of talk to you and, you know, and whatnot and vice versa. So what we did is we started Research for Impact 1.0, which was an online platform and it was a LinkedIn style online platform in which researchers and practitioners and policymakers, though, admittedly, at the beginning, it was mostly researchers and nonprofit practitioners, could build profiles. And then the idea, just like with like LinkedIn or many online platforms, is that they could then reach out to each other and they could initiate new collaborative relationships. So this is what the homepage looked like. If you were to go to our homepage today, it looks a little bit different. But this is what it looked like back then. And, you know, so what would happen is people would build these profiles and, you know, the profiles include a lot of different information. And so it would include, you know, things like, you know, sort of some basic demographic information.

[4:25](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=265) But then also a lot of questions about like your work. What kinds of what are your kind of goals right now? What sorts of collaboration have you done in the past? What are you looking for in the future? What areas do you work in both geographic but also substantive? You know, and things like that. So within the first 10 months in 2017, 388 people, and they got 388 smiley faces, had built profiles. And what that means is that they like, you know, overcame like a wide variety of barriers in the sense that like, you know, clearly they were interested. Otherwise, they wouldn't have done it. Clearly, they, you know, had some excess capacity, time, you know, so on and so forth. Otherwise, they wouldn't have done it. Obviously, they had taken advantage of an opportunity because they had built these profiles. And so in a lot of ways, and what these profiles contained, you know, it's hard to sort of summarize them neatly. But, you know, it was a wide variety of people who were interested in the social determinants of health broadly, which my hunch is very much the case of a lot of folks in the room right now.

[5:33](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=333) You know, these were people who were sort of either studying, like doing research on and or leading programs on and or designing policies to combat poverty, to improve nutrition, to improve transportation options, to increase voting, to build political constituencies, you name it. You know, it really like wide variety of sort of like social determinants of health broadly defined kinds of challenges. And that was true, again, on like really both sides, both the researchers and the practitioners. And so and they overcome all these barriers. And in a lot of ways, based on sort of like essentially vanity metrics, you know, we were doing really, really well, right? Because we had like 380 people who built these profiles within the first 10 months, which, you know, was like was amazing. There was only one problem. Even though 388 people had built profiles from the research community, from the practitioner community, we had a handful of policymakers on there as well.

[6:33](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=393) Only seven people had actually reached out to anybody else. And so what we had was essentially 388, like, you know, well-crafted profiles with pictures and the whole nine yards sitting on this site. But yet, basically, you know, nobody was using it for its intended purpose. From from the perspective of our theory of change, things were not going well. So that was disappointing. I mean, like, honestly, like I just thought, like, you know, I have to just sort of like tell you that, like, you know, by the time we got to the end of 2017, like, it was very, like, dispiriting, because we had spent like, you know, a lot of time, like kind of to just sort of set up the website. I mean, to come up with the website, to set it up, to like advertise it, to get people to build profiles, answer questions, all this whole nine yards. But yet it clearly wasn't working. And moreover, by the end of 2017, you know, we were at the point where, I mean, you all can probably like completely relate to this, that like, you know, information online about sort of what kinds of like projects you want to do, what your goals are, things like that, you know, had shifted, because people had different priorities by that point.

[7:38](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=458) And so we sort of faced this kind of like do or die moment at the end of 2017, where we sort of said, look, like, you know, should we try to get people to update stuff? Or like, is this just sort of not working? And so, you know, what I started to do, I, you know, after I kind of was like, got over the initial, like, you know, kind of sense, once I sort of admitted to myself, and we admitted to ourselves, like, this wasn't working, you know, the question was like, all right, like, let me sort of like put on my research hat for a second. Because it wasn't working. But it was like, kind of surprising that it wasn't working. And the reason why it was surprising was because the people who had built these profiles, they had overcome, as I said earlier, all of these like barriers that would seem to be really important. That, you know, clearly, they had desire and interest, otherwise, they wouldn't have done it, built the profile, right? Clearly, they had some capacity, otherwise, they wouldn't have built profile. Clearly, they take advantage of an opportunity. And all of those are like some of the major barriers to collaboration.

[8:41](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=521) You know, I mean, sometimes I think people use the term, like, or, you know, people refer to say, organizational incentives. And I'm sort of lumping that under sort of desire and interest, right? Clearly, like, they thought, you know what, this is something that like, I could do, maybe I should do whatever it is, right? But yet, like, nobody was reaching out to anybody else. The other thing that was sort of interesting is that they are rather so what I once I sort of like, realize that this was sort of surprising, I actually started reaching out to people, and I would ask them questions, you know, basically on the lines of like, you know, oh, I'm just really curious, you know, you built these profile, but you haven't really used the site, you know, is there any, is there anything wrong with it? Right? You know, did we kind of screw up in some way, you know, when we designed it? And, you know, what was fascinating with these responses is that, like, you know, the kinds of things that you might have expected to, like, have people say, like, well, you know, I don't really know how to collaborate, you know, or something like that. That's what people said, like, people sort of, like, got a sense, like, you know, they sort of know, sort of, like, broadly speaking, like, kind of how to do it. There's guides out there for like, kind of how to do it.

[9:49](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=589) You know, that wasn't really the issue. Some people said, like, you know, well, I'm not really certain, you know, kind of, like, sort of, you know, like, whether, like, now is a good time or not. And so there was a little bit of that, but like, not that much. But really, by and large, what people sort of expressed to me was sort of like, all of these barriers associated with essentially reaching out to strangers. Because that was really the key. What the Research for Impact online platform required for its success was that strangers felt comfortable reaching out to each other for new collaborative relationships. And what I was observing, and I'm going to unpack this a little bit more in a little bit, was essentially that, like, they don't feel comfortable doing that, even though they have joined the network, and even though they know other people have joined the network, specifically for this goal. Okay, so that's sort of like the end of my story. What I want to do is I want to sort of segue now into sort of thinking about you and your goals, and in particular, your goals for collaborative relationships. So with that in mind, I want to do, first of all, I want to share this, and then I want to ask you some questions.

[10:58](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=658) So my starting premise, and I want you to know that, like, I have gotten the, like, green light from Hannah on this. And so my hope is that, like, folks look at this and say, yes, that sounds like me, as opposed to, why am I here? So you run programs or design policies that seek to improve communities you care about, and you believe that new collaborative relationships are important for making further progress. And so my starting premise for, like, why we are here this afternoon is that basically, like, this applies to you. And I guess I'll put it, like, a little bit differently, which is to say that, like, you know, for the policies and programs that you work on, the, you know, it might be amazing if you had a bigger budget. It might be amazing if you had, like, more staff. Like, that, like, could totally be amazing. That could even be transformative, right? But either, like, you don't have that or you won't have that in the near future, and or even if you had that, it is still the case that, like, you know, new collaborative relationships would be important for making progress on the kinds of challenges that you're facing.

[12:09](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=729) And so that's kind of, that's my sort of starting premise. And so, and my hope is, is that for everybody in the room, you look at that and you say, like, yeah, all right, I can get behind that. If not, we'll look at the participant count drop for the next, like, 30 seconds. So that's the first thing. So what I want to do now is I want to sort of give you a chance to sort of think about, like, your collaboration goals. And in order to sort of motivate that, I'm going to put five questions on the screen. And this is one of those moments where, especially online, it's a little bit hard to kind of do this. If we were in person, you know, there's ways to sort of get folks sort of interacting with each other in the room and things like that. And it's a little bit hard to do that in kind of in an online space. But I want to sort of just, like, raise these questions and then give you some time to answer them yourself. And then what I'm going to do is I'm going to sort of ask folks to share a little bit with the room, anybody who feels comfortable, and we'll do that for a bit.

[13:10](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=790) And then I'm going to sort of talk a little bit more about sort of, like, why I'm asking these questions. Where do they come from? Why do I think they're important? And so on and so forth. All right. So the first question. How does the success, and I'm just going to, like, read them all and then put them on the screen. How does the success of your program or policy relate to what is happening elsewhere? So these are decision makers or community stakeholders, and I mean that very broadly, who have information that would help improve the effectiveness of your work. And this might be people from other agencies within government, this could be community members, this could be leaders of advocacy organizations, it could be researchers, it could be other data experts, anybody like that. So again, let me just go through all the questions. That's question number one. Question number two. Would you be looking for informal collaboration? By that I mean knowledge exchange. And or would you be looking for formal collaboration, which we can define as new projects over which you share ownership, decision making authority, and accountability.

[14:15](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=855) I want to also be clear that I think for some folks in the room, it might be that, like, you yourself might be looking for that. It is also the case that I think there's organizational leaders in the room for whom, like, you might basically have people within your organization who, like, you know, that they might want that. So I'm sort of, I want to allow for both. And then the third question is, what hesitations do you have about interacting with them? And what hesitations do you think they might have interacting with you? And this could be capacity, it could be interest, it could be stereotypes, it could be lack of permission, any other relational concerns. Question four. Why should they want to engage in a collaborative relationship with you? So what I want you to do is take like just a few minutes, and I'm going to leave these questions up. I'll keep sharing my screen. Just take like literally like, you know, two and a half minutes, three minutes. I'll go until 2.20 my time, just to answer them.

[15:17](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=917) And then what I'll do afterwards is I will unshare my screen so we can see each other. And I'm going to ask folks just to share answers to one or more of them. Okay, so just take like, again, just like a couple minutes, jot down answers to one or more of them and then we'll come back. Just in two minutes. And then we'll come back.

[16:17](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=977) And then we'll come back. And then we'll come back.

[17:17](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=1037) And then we'll come back. And then I will stop sharing my screen. Okay. All right, so I'm going to, let's see if I can put the gallery on. I know that a lot of folks are not sharing their, their camera which is totally fine. But, um, now.

[18:20](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=1100) I will just invite you all that if you are in a position where you could just turn on your camera for a few minutes that please do. It's also very nice for us to see your faces. So is there any so let's just I just want to spend a couple minutes and ask anybody who is so motivated maybe it's like raise your hand and just share and answer what your answers are to one or more doesn't have to be all of them, just whichever one you know particularly first spoke to you. Who wants to, who wants to go first. All of us always admire the person who goes first.

**Unknown speaker**

[19:03](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=1143) And if any I can you can either just jump in or raise your hand. Lena. Are you. Yay. Thank you.

**Audience**

[19:18](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=1158) I was thinking about several of your questions, in the sense that I do. The reason why I'm here, as you said is because I believe in the power of collaboration. And in my personal case I just I recently graduated, and I graduated with my master's thesis talking about how to improve the visa situation for immigrants here in Italy. In order to lower the impact that it has on us immigrants and our mental health. And of course it was just a theoretical proposal, but since I graduated. I'm in a transitional period to God somehow. I have been exploring demo operations here in Italy, governmental universities, some colleagues to try and develop my theoretical proposal and just figure out if the framework that I use is or not effective. And I have found myself with some good sites and bad sites.

[20:23](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=1223) I'm going to be addressing your third question to be more particular, and it's what's the hesitations. Do you have about interacting with other people and the hesitations that other people have interacted. In my personal case, I am, even though I'm trying to overcome this a very shy person, and I am very self critical with myself so I tend to expect people not believing in me since I just graduated. I don't have that much experience. And I am, as I just said it a transitional period of my life. I have found out very interesting responses and a lot of people open to chat and interact and put some input to to my research, which has been amazing and very satisfying to see. I haven't gotten yet to the point to be actually able to start the research, so I'm still working on that, but just the fact that people are responding and open to operation has been something that I honestly wasn't expecting.

**Adam Seth Levine**

[21:27](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=1287) So, really great. Great, thank you. I'm going to not respond individual ones just to give people more time to talk, but we're going to come back to this point for sure. Erwin.

**Audience**

[21:38](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=1298) Hi, in the government agency that I work in, everybody was really busy because we had a lot of things going on, especially during the change of hybrid and all those kinds of activities. And so, reaching out to others became very challenging when you have no time, and you don't have additional hands to help do the coordination with the others you're not directly connected with, basically. So, more work was essentially for three, four and five. It's like, we just didn't have the capacity.

**Adam Seth Levine**

[22:15](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=1335) Okay, great. Thank you. Next, maybe just a couple more, and then we'll go back to some of the slides. Anybody else? I know there's at least one other person who's like, there we go. Maria.

**Audience**

[22:43](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=1363) The government agency I'm working for is the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. For my project, I do a lot on the data sets, also calculating the regressive models. The agency, it's very big. Normally, I work on my project and share with my supervisor about the progress. Occasionally, I meet with my supervisor to discuss about what I have been doing, what I have done, and if it looks good or anything like that. We have some collaboration together. Me and another student, also another intern, it's in the Division of Data, the same department that I am in, and work under the same supervisor. We work on the project, both of our projects are on data analysis, but it's kind of different projects.

[23:52](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=1432) I think we have been interacting very good, and the project has been interesting. I really enjoyed the times that we interact together and how we engage in what we are doing.

**Adam Seth Levine**

[24:12](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=1452) The collaboration is very helpful. Yeah, thank you. It looks like there's a couple of comments in the chat. The fear of losing control, I think it's definitely something that I want to come back to in a bit, because that is very much something that I have seen in a lot of the examples that I've looked into as well. Let me, for now, I'm going to go back. Oh, Jenny, do one more.

**Audience**

[24:45](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=1485) I can make it quick. No, no. I work in Colorado and promote employment of people with disabilities, and there's a collaboration between multiple state agencies, and we've got folks at the table that are provider agencies and advocates and all of that. There's a lot of willingness to be there, but I really love your second question, because I think it's the heart of where we're at right now. Are we looking for informal collaboration, or are we looking at a space where there's ownership and accountability? Because I think we're kind of getting stuck there, because everybody's willing to be a partner, but no one wants to tell anybody else what to do or wants to assume that other people have capacity. Especially considering that there's turnover in positions, and when you have a government agency, one person might commit to something, but then if their position changes or if they move on, then is there still that level of commitment from that organizational level, or was it more of a personal commitment?

[25:48](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=1548) I really appreciate these questions, because I think that taking it back as a group to help us wrangle what we're thinking of will help us be able to move forward in what we're wanting out of it.

**Adam Seth Levine**

[25:57](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=1557) Thank you. Really, thank you for sharing. One of the things that is going to basically be a through line between the next hour that we have together is making things explicit that are often implicit or are not asked or things like that. I think that one of the things about these questions, and maybe actually let me go back to sharing my screen, is that none of them are rocket science in any way, but what they are is simply a way to make things explicit that at least one thing I've learned over time does not necessarily happen automatically. Let me talk for a bit more. I'm going to talk for a bit. I will then actually probably pause for questions. Maybe I'll even stop sharing the screen just to see if anybody has questions, and then I can keep going for a bit.

[26:58](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=1618) Why did I ask these questions? So far, I've talked about the Research for Impact online platform experience and how that didn't work, and then I asked you these questions. One of the things that really sort of hit me by the online platform experience, the Research for Impact 1.0 experience, was that essentially what I was observing was that there could be this thing called unmet desire to collaborate, which is that new collaborative relationships that people would value don't necessarily arise on their own. And the other thing I was observing is that that was the case basically like regardless of sort of multiple goals for those collaborative relationships. And so this was sort of the idea that like, you know, you might want to sort of have an interactive back and forth relationship with somebody where the goal is simply like knowledge exchange, so informal collaboration. But it could also be that your ultimate goal is to engage in a project with shared ownership, decision-making authority, and accountability.

[28:00](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=1680) Or it could really be sort of something kind of in between where essentially you want to maybe coordinate your decisions, but you don't like officially sort of have shared decision-making authority. I think that was certainly true like among like say public health agencies, many public health agencies during the pandemic. And so, but collaborative relationships can have multiple goals. And, you know, on the one hand, this is like I think sort of like obvious to put this on the screen and point it out. But one thing I have often found is that like the word collaboration tends, it means different things to different people. And it really often sort of connotes this idea of the more formal type. But the thing is, is that informal, the knowledge exchange is like sometimes all the people need and or want. And moreover, you know, you can have one, you can have sort of something that starts informal and maybe becomes formal or vice versa, you know, over time. And just to kind of be like even a little bit more specific, I mean, the Research for Impact online platform, when people build these profiles, a lot of people said, you know, like, for example, we had a lot of practitioners who said, you know, I would love to just sort of talk about like, what is the research on, you know, voter engagement like say, you know, or what is the best, what is the research on like, you know, how best to communicate about climate change?

[29:17](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=1757) What does it say? Give me an overview. You know, something like that. And, you know, that is very much kind of like in thinking about the kind of informal type. And so I think it's really important to sort of distinguish between both of them and name and legitimize both of them. The other thing which I mentioned before a bit is the new collaborators often begin as strangers. And strangers can be uncertain and or hesitant about their ability to interact with each other. And that certainly came out in a couple of the comments that folks made from earlier, especially Lena's comment and stuff, but like, but more generally as well. So, so there's this thing called unmet desire. You might sort of ask this question of kind of like, all right, well, why might desire remain unmet? And so a number of folks have mentioned a number of things, and I want to sort of put a full list here for completeness in a way. One is, you know, lack of time. That was Erwin's comment for sure, right? Like, absolutely, right? And so lack of opportunity, you know, no one asked, you know, things like that. Never thought of it, no one asked.

[30:20](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=1820) Lack of organizational incentives and or sort of, you know, particularly for folks within a bureaucracy, say, lack of like, you know, explicit permission. Absolutely. But so there are these other things that, you know, that Research for Impact online platform creators, profile builders, had expressed to me that, you know, was really sort of like, kind of, again, sort of making explicit things that often, like, really go implicit, which is basically like this uncertainty about how to relate to others, right? And that really could take on lots of different forms. In some cases, it was about like, I'm uncertain how to engage with someone new. In some cases, it was uncertainty about how others will engage with you. It was also uncertainty about whether other what others collaboration goals were, and in particular, people were very uncertain about, you know, is it okay, essentially, to just be looking for informal collaboration? Like, there's a sense that, like, you know, if all I really want is knowledge exchange, like, can I really just have, like, you know, a pen pal or something like that, or something like that, you know?

[31:32](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=1892) And people were really kind of uncertain about that. But there were, you know, behind these things, this is how I'm summarizing it, but just to even, like, kind of put a little bit more meat on the bones, you know, people would say to me things like, you know, I don't feel like I know what's appropriate or inappropriate to say. It's like, like script concerns. I don't, you know, I'm not really sure how to start the conversation, right? Things like, I don't know if the other person is really going to value my knowledge or expertise. Things like, I don't know if the other person is actually going to be interested in talking to me. Things like, you know, I don't know whether I can trust the other person. Things like, I don't really know, you know, whether the other person really has sort of like knowledge that would be practical for me, or domain specific for me. And I think it's actually really interesting the way that they, like, people would separate those out. Like, you can be like, you know, a huge domain expert in, like, in a particular way, but still not necessarily be able to make that knowledge practical, you know, or things like that. Now, status-based stereotypes absolutely heighten the uncertainty. And when I use the term status-based stereotypes, I mean sort of situations where people's that people's knowledge or expertise around the topic is sort of tied to some stereotype that folks have about them.

[32:47](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=1967) And so this, like, often sort of takes the form of sort of, you know, that certain kinds of people are seen as being experts on certain kinds of things. And conversely, people sort of, you know, might worry about their expertise not being recognized or valued in certain in certain spaces. And so just to, like, put an example on that, that sounds kind of vague. Just to put an example on it, like, people have written about, for example, the Flint water crisis. Remember, I'm a public health professor, so I'm using public health examples. People have written about the public, the Flint water crisis, you know, like, have talked about sort of, like, lots of examples in which, like, the the families who were experiencing, like, you know, the brown water and the lost hair and, like, other kinds of things. And this was often really, you know, I'm saying families, but really it was often, like, mothers would sort of not necessarily have their expertise recognized when they went to public meetings. Right. And, you know, I think that's an example of sort of status based stereotypes, basically getting in the way of, you know, of people relating to others in the ways that they would like.

[33:49](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=2029) The other thing that can heighten that uncertainty is political divides. And when I say political divides, that can also mean, I think, a number of different things. What I'm really especially thinking about is sort of that you know, when we are in a more polarized environment, people can often be motivated by, can often experience more of a group based motivation than an accuracy based motivation. And so what that means is that when they meet new people or when they think about interacting with new people, they process what those people have to say more in terms of whether they're on my side, whether they're perceived to be part of my group, and not so much in terms of whether the information that they are sharing is accurate in some way. And so it's kind of you talk about sort of group based motivation, as opposed to accuracy based motivation, and that can really sort of get in the way of recognizing other people's expertise. And I want to just sort of say, like, you know, that kind of just to sort of sum up, this is the last thing I want to say on this slide, that, like, you know, when we talk about sort of collaborative relationships, like the whole idea of them is that people with diverse forms of expertise are engaging in back and forth in order to sort of try to improve a community that they care about, to better understand problems, think about how to solve them, evaluate things you've done in the past, so on and so forth.

[35:06](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=2106) And so we're very interested in how can we ensure that people with this diverse form of expertise, and I'm using the word expertise here very broadly, you know, can actually sort of like choose to interact with each other and then do so fruitfully. Okay, so that's all of sort of the kind of like theoretical, so I, you know, we did the questions, this is all kind of like theoretical stuff. I want to actually present some like some findings and some data that kind of are interesting and help to sort of like show the power of some of this stuff. In particular, sort of how to like, like why this relationality stuff matters and how to actually overcome this uncertainty. But let me just sort of like Stop sharing my screen for one more second and just ask if anybody has any questions at this point. The answer might be no, but I just figure it's an opportunity just to kind of like also break up me talking. So anyways, anybody have any questions. And really, it can be anything at all. You can ask me where I got my shirt. And, you know, ask me where I got my glasses. That's totally fine. But, or you can tell me that you are like dying to hear more. Thank you, Tina. I really appreciate the little laughing face. Okay, so, um, uh, yeah. Any, any, if anybody has any questions or anything like that. And then we'll go back to I'll show you some cool data. It's really cool, by the way.

[36:24](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=2184) All right. Question. Oh, uh, oh, wait, somebody just like spoke, but Sorry, no more can go first. He raised his hand.

**Unknown speaker**

[36:31](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=2191) Okay, actually can't even see who's talking. Anyway, Mark over to you.

**Audience**

[36:36](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=2196) I'm loving this so far. Really, really helpful to hear. And so I am part of an organization that's building a professional association community. So trying to connect people that all work in the government space and public sector space. And one of the things that we've definitely heard, and you sort of mentioned this before, is the fear of the first sort of outreach right being the first person to sort of start the conversation with people that they don't know and and the piece that you mentioned about the status element. I'm curious, like, does that end up being a factor in people Raising their voice or start a conversation in in spaces where they just don't know people and they might sort of like put in their own minds like this status element as well. Or how does that, how does that play into, you know, when you have like a large group that's not anonymous but fairly unknown to each other. Yeah, no, um, thank you for that question. And it's a great question. I think that you know what

**Adam Seth Levine**

[37:34](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=2254) What's interesting about status based stereotypes is that sometimes they can lead people to not talk. And it can be for any number of reasons, like what I mentioned, but I mean, especially things like I don't think that my, you know, expertise will be valued. I don't think people care about talking to me. I don't think people will be interested. People might act like I'm annoying them, you know, it could be a what can kind of it can manifest in a few different ways. And and so that so it can stop people from talking. I think, alternatively, can actually encourage people to talk, who may be, you know, actually know less about the topic, then they might think they do. And and or, you know, the other people might sort of pay more attention to them, then maybe is warranted. And so, or at least relatively speaking. And so, like, overall, it's sort of it skews things. Now, you know, it's the question of sort of how to like overcome that and how to sort of how can people, you know, one of the well actually, I guess I'll say a couple things. One is that, like, it's really hard to overcome stereotypes, like I actually sort of talked to I have a number of friends who do research, you know, specifically kind of on stereotypes. And, you know, they say it's really, really hard to overcome stereotypes, but it's really hard to overcome stereotypes.

[38:45](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=2325) And, you know, they say it's really, really hard. What is easier in a way is just sort of like and what often happens is that if you gain enough knowledge about somebody, you sort of like carve them up as an exception to like, you know, to a stereotype, but doesn't it may or may not necessarily like change the underlying stereotype. But one of the kind of, you know, ways in which, you know, people can sort of overcome stereotypes is to try to individuate as much as possible to sort of gain as much like knowledge, like focus on the individual as possible. And there's a few different ways to sort of that you can do that to other people, but also sort of try to demonstrate that you want to like that you welcome that information from others. And in fact, actually one of the some of the data I'm going to present actually right after this Q&A part is going to speak directly to that. So what I would say is like there's a little bit of like of a response, but some of the data that's coming up will also speak to it. But then also what's also interesting about kind of relationality and stereotypes in general is that they are very sort of like context specific. And so one of the kind of challenges in a way is always sort of getting a sense of like, you know, what might people be uncertain about or what kinds of specific stereotypes might they hold in a particular context.

[40:00](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=2400) And so that like it's kind of speaks to the sort of translation of the kind of theoretical ideas to particular context. But again, I'm going to show an example of that in a second. There's somebody else who started speaking, but I don't see another hand.

**Audience**

[40:14](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=2414) Oh, that was me. Caitlin. I just was going to comment that I really appreciated the example you used of someone from the public speaking and not necessarily being seen as someone with expertise or experience. In my role with the town of Chapel Hill, I focus on community engagement, but specifically with equity in mind, which means that I focus on immigrant and refugee residents. I think, as you said, we kind of also like self, you know, self maybe like identify ourselves as expertise as experts or not. And I think that like that lived experience historically has not been seen as as expertise, but it's something that our municipality is working on incorporating as something that's valuable. So I think I'm interested in hearing and like other ways that people are doing that, because it is particularly sensitive to work with people that come from historically disenfranchised backgrounds to build that trust.

[41:15](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=2475) Because, you know, even if we can, talking about unmet desires, they've had a history of that, right, you know, and so like I just am curious about learning more about that, I guess.

**Adam Seth Levine**

[41:27](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=2487) Yeah, no, thank you for those questions. And let me, I'm going to respond to two pieces. One is, I really want to underscore how much I agree with the point about kind of thinking about expertise broadly, and especially defining lived experience as a form of expertise. And that is something that I personally go to great lengths to do. And in fact, actually, you're going to see that in the next study I'm going to present, like sort of the way in which I try to operationalize that in that one particular context. And so I really want to sort of like kind of like emphasize how much I agree with that point. On the other point, actually, about sort of like working with like communities. So I won't, I have like a lot of different examples and sort of depending on usually who I'm talking to about this kind of stuff, I sort of pull out some and not others. And because I knew that this was a room of policymakers, I didn't plan to sort of talk quite as much about sort of forming, say, like, kind of like community-based participatory research kinds of examples between researchers and community groups.

[42:30](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=2550) But I am happy to talk about that during Q&A or to kind of talk afterwards to you as well as really to anybody else, because a lot of the matchmaking work that Research for Impact does is between, and oh, I should say, well, I'm kind of, this is a little bit of a spoiler alert. So Research for Impact now is very different from the online platform. So we do hands-on matchmaking now, and I'll mention that a little bit at the end. But so through that hands-on matchmaking, which has been way more successful than the online platform, a lot of the kinds of matches will often sort of focus on sort of bringing together, like, say, you know, environmental researchers and, say, environmental justice organizations, like, you know, and other groups that are trying to, like, you know, working on issues related to immigration, trying to get, you know, increased voter turnout, like, you know, you name it. And so I'm happy to talk about more examples of that, either during Q&A or afterwards. Well, so let me keep going for a bit on the slides. And again, so, like, just to give you a heads up, I mean, I'm thinking, like, we have 45 minutes left. I'm going to basically talk for, like, another, like, 25 minutes or so, 20 minutes or so. And then we'll definitely have more time for Q&A at the end. So that's kind of, that's what's coming. So let me go back to sharing my screen.

[43:48](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=2628) And get this off of there. So the two main takeaways, I mean, just like the, like, super high level is simply, first of all, there can be this unmet desire. And I mentioned that simply to say that, like, my attitude, whether good, bad, or otherwise, is basically, I look out in the world, and I see a lot of, like, possibility that is often just not, like, being realized for a variety of reasons, not necessarily for bad reasons. But, like, I sort of, so I think, like, you know, I want to encourage you, and I, you know, people will push back on this, and that's totally fine. But, like, I definitely want to sort of encourage you to think that, like, there can be this unmet desire to collaborate out there. And either that we might have it in ourselves, and or other people who, you know, have expertise as relevant to the policies and programs that we are working on have as well. And then uncertainty about relationality is one key and often overlooked reason why. And I say often overlooked, because when I often, when I talk to people about sort of collaboration, and sort of, you know, talk about, like, you know, why it isn't necessarily happening on its own collaborative relations, why they aren't happening on their own, and things like that, like, often the immediate response is something like, well, you know, there's not a lot of time.

[45:00](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=2700) takes a lot of money, and things like that. And not to say that that's not important, those things are totally important. But I think it's interesting the way in which when I, you know, press people, you know, to kind of think about other kinds of factors, there are these other things that I think people don't always maybe sort of voice, that can really kind of stop them dead in their tracks. And I think it's super interesting, because there are many moments in our daily life, right, where we interact with strangers, and we don't give it a second thought. I mean, you know, when I go and order lunch at a restaurant that I've never been to, I don't even, you know, I don't typically, like, sort of, you know, like, stop from doing so, because I'm not really certain what to say. No, I mean, I kind of know what's appropriate or inappropriate to say when the waiter or waitress comes over, and they know what's appropriate or inappropriate to say as well. And you kind of have these expectations for what we're doing. I mean, I'm not going to order my lunch and then be asked to go cook it in the back, right? Like, that's just not a thing that's going to happen. We're not going to, like, go off and, like, formally collaborate to, like, chop peppers together. Like, that's just not what's going to happen, right? And so it's, you know, but it's interesting, right, how, like, in those moments, like, I am interacting with a stranger, and it typically goes fine. But yet here, and I think in so many other places, that is not necessarily the case for a variety of reasons. All right, so I want to sort of present, like, some data. And I'm just going to sort of, let me just say right off the bat that, like, you know, I know a lot of folks in the room, at least Hannah has told me a lot of folks in the room, and also from reading the chat box before, you know, our policymakers, state level, municipal level, and, you know, the examples I'm going to present are not, or at least this example, rather, is not going to relate necessarily, it's not necessarily going to directly sort of, like, speak to, like, you know, your context, okay? But there is a broader theoretical point that comes out of them. So all of these are basically, like, surveys or randomized controlled trials that are testing kind of broad hypotheses. And so I just want to kind of say that out front, because I know that the context is going to, that some of you might

[47:01](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=2821) look at the context and be like, why am I here? Like, you know, it's lunchtime, he was just talking about food, why am I here? All right, so I, but anyway, so I want to make sure to sort of pull that out. So first of all, I want to show, like, what is the impact of directly communicating relationality? And also just kind of what can that look like? So this was a study that I did, this is going to be a randomized controlled trial that I did with a 501c3 nonprofit organization that builds awareness of climate solutions in chapters across the US. And so what they have is they have group leaders in 456 different chapters across the country, covering most congressional districts. And these are volunteer folks. And really what they're doing is they're basically sort of, you know, you know, creating awareness of climate solutions. And they're also sort of building relationships with their local, with their elected representatives, locally, as well as on Capitol Hill, as well as in state capitals and things like that. And so in early 2019, one of the challenges that they were facing was sustaining volunteer engagement. Because what had been happening basically was that after, particularly kind of after the Trump administration came in, they pulled out of the Paris Agreement, what this organization was seeing was this, like, huge influx of people to their meetings. And I'm sure many of you can relate to this, right?

[48:19](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=2899) Like, you know, you go to these meetings, you're, like, super fired up and whatnot. And, like, the problem is, is that, like, you know, if all you ever do is basically keep going to meetings, you're going to eventually stop going. And so you have these, like, leaders, these group leaders, who are sort of like, look, like, you know, we're getting all these people showing up to these rooms, but, like, we need to, like, get, we need to somehow, like, give them things to do. We can't have just them coming to meetings. They're going to stop coming, right? And so what they wanted, so that was one of the challenges, sort of, like, what do we know based on the research on volunteerism and things like that? And there is a whole body of research on, like, kind of volunteerism and, you know, how do you sort of sustain volunteer engagement and things like that? Like, what does it say that might be helpful for us? Like, kinds of what are tips and tricks and things like that that we could use, that group leaders could use? Okay? So what I did is I work with this organization to say, all right, let's basically, like, try to build new collaborative relationships between experts on that topic, so the volunteerism and volunteer engagement, stuff like that, and these group leaders, who, speaking of, like, lived experience, bring a wealth of expertise to their chapters. They know their chapters better than anybody else.

[49:27](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=2967) And so the idea was sort of, like, you know, and this is sort of a way of also me kind of, like, being, putting a little bit of meat on the bones in terms of collaborative relationship, and this is an example of informal collaboration, that essentially, like, you know, what they could do is sort of if you brought, you know, you brought the researcher who knows about, like, the research on volunteer engagement, but, you know, that was conducted at a different time, in a different place, et cetera, and then you have the group leader who has all this expertise on the local place, the history of it, what the specific challenges are, and things like that, that if they could have a back and forth, they could sort of take the research-based insights and sort of figure out what would be feasible and what might work well in their local place, and that's kind of the idea. So with that in mind, what we varied, and this is the randomized control trial part of it, we varied the outreach, because what we were also concerned about, and the we in this case is me, and then the head of this organization, and so not a group leader, but basically the person who sort of, like, oversees all the group leaders, and what we did is we varied the outreach, because, as she said to me in advance, she's like, you know, look, like, you know, I don't know that these group leaders are going to want, like, want to interact with a researcher, and remember, like, you know, they're starting off as strangers, also, I mean, this is voluntary, nobody has to, like, no group leader has to interact with the researcher or vice versa, you know, it's all voluntary, and so, you know, they might be uncertain about things, and so that's what we did, is what we did is we varied the outreach to try to basically overcome two forms of uncertainty about relationality that we thought that the group leaders might have, so let me just show you what this looked like, and by the way, I'm, like, super excited to share this with you, because in part what it's doing is sort of, like, making, again, kind of making explicit things that are often, I think, implicit or left unsaid, and so, like, often the reaction, of course, you know, you don't have to have this reaction, but often the reaction when I present these findings are people like, oh, you know, it's like, I never really thought about, you know, studying something like that, or, like, even necessarily being as explicit about this as you

[51:27](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=3087) were, so, all right, so the group leaders are randomly assigned to one of four groups, and what we did is we varied the email outreach, and so there was a baseline group that got just, like, you know, basically we're offering you this opportunity, I'll show you what that looked like in a second, I'll put it on the next screen, the bit with the baseline message was, then we added a little bit of information about what detail, what information might be shared to the group, you know, if you interacted with the researcher, and then we had two treatments that aimed to explicitly overcome uncertainty about relationality. One was emphasizing that the researcher understood that the group leader was busy and was going to basically sort of, like, efficiently share what they knew, and then, and the idea, again, being that, like, the group leader might be uncertain about, like, interacting with the researcher who's just going to go on and on and on about, like, whatever, and then the second one was basically that the group leader might be uncertain about whether the researcher would actually value their expertise, and sort of trying to overcome that, and so, and then the outcome was, was a behavioral outcome, did they want to informally collaborate, and again, when I say informally collaborate, I mean, did they want to have a back and forth interaction, did the group leader want to have a back and forth interaction with the researcher about this challenge related to volunteer engagement?

[52:47](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=3167) Okay, I'm not going to go through this in detail. This was the baseline message, and all it was, was basically just saying simply, you know, like, here's this organ, you know, we're offering you this opportunity to connect with a researcher, and it was, you know, it was a partnership with my organization, Research for Impact, that's why that's in bold, but anyway, you know, we know you want to strengthen your volunteer base, you know, there's this organization that builds these connections, you know, are you interested in being connected? That's like kind of all this was. The treatment groups basically had an extra paragraph that was added in the middle, so right where that red arrow is, and so what I'm going to do is I'm really just going to show you sort of like what that looked like, and so the signaling that you will efficiently share what you know, it looked like this. We said previous participants reported that it, so this interaction, interaction was an extremely efficient experience. The researchers acknowledged that folks are busy and don't have time to keep up on all the latest research that they might wish to, so the name of the game is efficiency. They provide a concentrated dose of news you can use, and that's like, and that was just in the middle, explicitly stated. The next, the other one, so that was one relationality treatment. The other relationality treatment was signaling that you value others' information, and so here we said, we added this paragraph. Previous participants reported that it was an extremely pleasant and affirming experience. They said that the researchers they spoke with were kind, respectful, genuinely interested in their work, and very clearly want to learn about their organizations, and that's all. So that what we're doing is we're just testing when we add either of these paragraphs to the outreach, does that increase people's willingness to interact, and you know, again, what I want to sort of emphasize with this is that like, what's going on here is like, nothing here is sort of like rocket science per se, but we are being explicit about sort of what happens when you say this, because otherwise it's left unsaid. So here are the findings.

[54:49](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=3289) So in the baseline group, we had 6.2 percent of people, of group leaders who wanted to connect. When we said that we would efficiently, the researchers would efficiently share what they knew, it shot up to 17.3 percent, and I want to sort of emphasize, by the way, that we only sent one email, like, so this is like 17.3 percent of people responding to one, you know, in that group responding to one email. When we said value others' information, it also shot up, not quite as much, but also shot up to 13.9 percent, and when we just shared more details about what, you know, what the conversation would look like, what would they, what would you be talking about, that was basically the same. I mean, it went down a little bit, but it was basically the same. And so I think with this underscore, so I mean, I want to sort of, you know, share this with you, because I think it's interesting to sort of see, like, how can you sort of be explicit about, you know, about, like, you know, how you're going to relate to others. That's really all this is, and it really had a pretty big effect. Okay, so that's all I'm going to say about this for now. I'll also say I'm more than happy to talk about, like, what happened after, like, what was the consequence of the informal collaboration, if folks are interested. But right now, I'm just sort of interested in kind of, like, looking at it as a, you know, just the initiation. So the other thing, so that is arguably something that, like, anybody can do themselves, in the sense that, like, you know, it's sort of a self-service strategy. Like, you know, we can, like, go to potential collaborators, and we can say those kinds of things explicitly, potentially, right? The other thing, though, is I know that, like, from talking to Hannah in advance, that, like, a lot of folks in the room, you know, you are organization leaders, or you might basically be a third party, where you look out in the world, and you say, you know what? Honestly, like, I think there's other people who might value collaboration, other kinds of collaborative relationships that might be valuable. And so another thing to think about is, like, that, you know, you can assess, one can assess, rather, unmet desire through just, like, asking people. So basically taking a version of those five questions from earlier, and just asking people. So what I want to do is just present a couple of

[56:52](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=3412) examples where I've done that, and this is sort of, it's kind of fun to present these to all of you, because these are actually surveys of local policymakers, local, and then this one's local, and the other one's going to be local and state. And so what I was interested in with these surveys, this one is just assessing an unmet desire for more evidence-informed policymaking process. And what I mean by that was basically asking a national sample of local policymakers, you know, to what extent do you interact with researchers from colleges and universities in your local region, and to what extent would you like to be, basically, and for what purpose. And so this is unmet desire for more evidence-informed policymaking process, 541 local policymakers all across the United States in spring of 2021. And so here's just a kind of overview of some of the findings. So what we found was that, like, when we asked, like, whether these, whether local policymakers interact with local researchers to tackle policy challenges, what we found was that, like, by and large, like, you know, they didn't. And so that's the tall green, dark green bar all the way on the left is basically saying that, like, they, you know, that close to 80 percent rarely had not had any, excuse me, had not had any collaborative relationships with local researchers over the past year. But yet, when we asked if you wanted, like, basically, like, more or less or the same, what we found was basically that a majority wanted more frequent collaboration. That's the light green bar all the way over on the right. So 57 percent said that they wanted more than what they have right now. Here we ask the question a little bit differently, which is basically, you know, have you gotten outreach by local researchers to collaborate on policy challenges you're facing in your work? And what we found is that almost 80 percent said that no, they had not. That's the dark green, the tall dark green bar. But then almost 80 percent said actually, yes, they would totally welcome unprompted outreach by a local researcher to

[58:52](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=3532) talk about policy challenges they are facing. And when we asked about the kinds of policy challenges, what we found was basically, like, an absolute sort of potpourri of all of the kinds of, like, you know, things that local policymakers deal with on a daily basis. And so people would say, like, you know, things like environmental issues, land use issues, climate adaptation, climate mitigation, you know, issues related to education, other public health issues. You name it, it was all over the policing, like all over the board. And these local policymakers, I should say, by the way, were a combination of county and municipal. We also, though, asked about the hesitations, because also I'm interested in sort of, you know, kind of surfacing those relational barriers. And so we gave people a list of eight of them. And so you can see them listed over on the left-hand side. And what we found was that, like, you know, basically almost 20 percent of people said, like, you know, yes to five out of the eight. And so, you know, there was one hesitation about interacting with local researchers, you know, that they may push a political agenda. That was a big one. But then also they may not have practical information, was another, like, fairly frequent one.

[1:00:00](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=3600) Interestingly enough, the concern about whether they might have practical information, so that's the 34.1, was substantially larger than, like, they might not have domain-specific expertise, which is the 18.6. I think it's interesting how there's a distinction there. Also, they may not value my knowledge and experience as a policymaker as about 18 percent. And so I think it's, you know, these are, you know, I think, like, you know, it's interesting and it's important to sort of surface, you know, this kind of stuff. And especially, I mean, to get almost 20 percent, you know, expressing, like, a number of these hesitancies, I think, is really quite noteworthy. Let me just present one other survey quickly, which is, this is a desire not for a more evidence-informed policymaking process, but a more ethics-informed policymaking process. And so here what we assessed was basically, how much do you interact with bioethicists? And so, you know, to tackle health challenges. And so this was three types of policymakers who make tough decisions related to the health of their community. These were the people who were being surveyed. And so we have local government elected policymakers, local government managers, and state and local government family support civil servants, people who do anything related to sort of family support. And so I'm guessing that, like, this probably encompasses a number of folks in the room, collectively, these three groups. And this was a little bit more recent.

[1:01:21](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=3681) This was actually almost exactly a year ago. And what we found, and I'll just present a couple of these, you know, just for now, but I'm happy to say more during Q&A, is that, like, across the three groups, like, almost no one had interacted with a bioethicist at least once over the past year. And I should say that what we did in the beginning of this survey, recognizing the term bioethicist, not necessarily a household term. There was a little description, sort of like, you know, what is a bioethicist? And so, but, you know, but almost no one really had said that they'd interacted with them over the past year. But yet, when we then asked, like, you know, do, would you like to be interacting with them more than you have been? You know, we found that, like, you know, actually, like, substantial percentages said yes. So basically, between 40 and 50 percent across the three different samples. And so again, sort of, you know, these are really just meant as, like, illustrative examples of asking these kinds of questions in policy contexts, especially, kind of, in, sort of, subnational policy contexts. Okay. So let me just, sort of, maybe just talk for, like, another, like, five to ten minutes and just say, you know, kind of, like, what are the, sort of, next steps? So, like, my hope in our time today is that I'm presenting, like, a little bit of, like, interesting stuff, but also actionable stuff that, you know, you can then, like, take away from this session. And, you know, you can, sort of, implement to maybe change your own thinking about your work, as well as, sort of, change, like, the kinds of conversations you're having with colleagues. Either you're already having them or maybe want to be having them.

[1:02:52](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=3772) And so I think, like, first of all, in terms of next steps, one is to, looks like somebody is off mute, that, so one of them is, like, you know, that you can take the five questions from earlier and use that as a starting point for deciding what kinds of new collaborative relationships you want and then how to connect people with diverse forms of expertise and news. So, again, that's in part, like, what might be valuable to you, what kinds of collaborative relationships might be valuable to you, but then also, sort of, like, you know, if you maybe could be a matchmaker or, you know, something like that. And I, sort of, especially want to call out this possibility of organization leaders as matchmakers, because I think that's, and really to, sort of, say, you know, that just also in the interest of, sort of, providing even a little bit more data, I'll just show you, sort of, what happens when Research for Impact started being more of an active matchmaker. So I presented, so, you know, an hour ago I presented Research for Impact 1.0, which was the online platform. That didn't work. And so what we did is we eventually, once people started, like, revealing all of these, like, relational barriers, we were, like, all right, you know, like, what do we do, you know? And so we said, all right, like, I was, like, let me start, basically, offering more hands-on matchmaking, where I'm basically going to go out to people, and I'm going to say, look, I'm going to prompt them, like, basically acting like an organization leader. I'm going to ask them, like, you know, are there challenges you're facing in your work where you think that interacting with somebody else might be helpful? And I varied the prompt depending upon who I was talking to. But it was very much, like, similar to what was asked in the surveys I just presented, similar to the kinds of questions, those five questions at the beginning of this talk. And I just, like, I prompted people. And it turned out that when I did that, people actually responded. And then from there, you know, I would actually make matches. And so I'll just present some of the data, because I think it's interesting just to see, you know, kind of, like, when people were given this opportunity, what happened. And so this is just from the early

[1:04:54](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=3894) matchmaking, so 2018, which is when we started doing this, and then to 2021. And, you know, what we found was basically that, like, you know, and this was both from researchers requesting matchmaking and practitioners requesting matchmaking, didn't focus too much on policymakers at the time. But what we found was that, like, we had 128 requests for informal collaboration, which could take a number of different forms. A lot of times it might be either to discuss a large research literature, maybe to make an immediate evidence-based decision, maybe to gain ideas about how to measure impact. So it could really take a number of different forms. But the tie that binds was it was really all about sort of knowledge sharing. And then in some cases, people were looking for more formal collaboration. And in our case, and I get that this might look different for folks in the room, but maybe not. But, like, it was to work on a new research project, where, again, there might be sort of shared ownership, decision-making authority, and accountability between the researcher and the practitioner. So just, I'm just sort of, I present that more of just, you know, I get that it's a little bit outside of the government context per se, but just to kind of give you a sense of, you know, what can happen. And I actually have other data on sort of, like, what, like, even the impact of all this is. If folks are interested, I'm happy to share that. It's in the extra slides. But just back to this. So next step. So one thing to do is to use the five questions. Organization leaders can prompt people with those questions and act as matchmakers. And I think one thing that's really interesting about, like, acting as a matchmaker that I just want to kind of mention is that, you know, you're bringing together people with diverse forms of expertise and who might be, you know, hesitant in a variety of ways to interact with each other. You know, after all, that's the whole purpose of having a third-party matchmaker, in a way. And so one thing that I think is really helpful, there's this technique called role assignment, where when you're bringing people together with diverse forms of expertise, and you think that, like, political divides might get in the way, you think status-based stereotypes might get in the way of them really having a productive exchange, one thing to do is to actually sort of very explicitly,

[1:06:58](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=4018) when connecting people, like, identify their task-relevant expertise to each other, make it common knowledge, and be super explicit about it. And what's helpful about that is it not only sort of demonstrates to you as the matchmaker, like, why you think they should be interacting, but it also helps to sort of act as conversation starters. Because when you tell somebody, oh, this person, like, you know, is, like, leads this community organization that has been seeing increasing flooding, it naturally lends itself to questions like, oh, like, you know, how much flooding are you seeing? How often is it happening? How are people responding? It, like, naturally sort of starts the conversation. And I often sort of talk about sort of, you know, kind of trying to grease the wheels of conversation. And then, so, you know, you'll notice that the large majority of what I've talked about is really about initiation. And the reason why I've talked about it is because that was the core challenge that the Research for Impact Profile Builders back in 2017, that's what they expressed to me. And, you know, there's so much out there about, like, how do you actually collaborate once you're together, right? You know, how do you interact with people once you're together? How do you basically, like, embark on a new project together once you're together? And so I want to just sort of, like, very explicitly call out the fact that, like, you know, I'm trying to focus on this initiation in part because I was seeing that as a huge barrier. And in fact, you know, that, like, you know, I think the specifics about sort of what you do next, if it's informal collaboration, then we can talk about sort of, like, you know, like, active listening and, you know, and how to sort of follow up and things like that.

[1:08:36](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=4116) If it's more formal collaboration, we can talk about sort of, you know, what do you need, what kinds of conversations do you have to have up front? What do you need to put in writing? What does a memorandum of understanding have to look like? Where is the funding going to come from? How can you ensure, this was a point that was mentioned earlier, how can you ensure that something you have buy-in from an organization, not just an individual? And we can talk about all that stuff. But I want to just sort of note, right, that, like, each of those things, and I know that Innovate US sort of, like, you know, hosts seminars on this as well. Each of those things is very specific to particular types of formal collaboration that are going to vary tremendously across people and organizations and stuff. But I want to sort of, you know, really kind of call out the fact that I'm very sort of consciously starting on this kind of, like, how do you get started? How do you connect people with diverse forms of expertise? Because it often doesn't happen on its own. Okay. Hannah said I could do this, which is to say that, like, so I do have this new book. And a lot of the kinds of things I've talked about, including sort of, like, what to do once you're interacting with people, you know, really does come from this book. And so I am just going to sort of make a plug for this.

[1:09:47](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=4187) And even if you sort of, like, don't care about the book at all, I'll at least sort of say I'm happy to take compliments on the cover. I'm happy to take compliments on the title. My husband came up with the title and the press kept it, which I was actually quite floored with. And so anyway, if you have any compliments on that, I'm happy to take that. But I did just want to sort of just point out that, like, this stuff is in here and, you know, that our time together is, you know, something that is similar to the kinds of workshops I lead with a wide variety of people who are trying to improve, like, you know, communities that they care about. And that's really the kind of, you know, expertise becoming useful in civic life that the subtitle is speaking to. And so with that, I'm just going to, I'll put this up one more time in case you forgot who on earth is this guy with the pattern shirt. And just to say the one thing I'm adding, and in the interest of overcoming uncertainty about relationality, which is I'm adding my email address at the bottom and saying, you know, I really do welcome folks to email me. And I'm happy to have, like, follow-up conversations because, you know, I think a lot of this stuff, you know, is, you know, it's again, hopefully interesting, hopefully actionable, but also is, I know that everybody's, like, challenges and contexts is different, right? And so, you know, even putting some of the, you know, in the interest of collaborative relationships, the spirit of collaborative relationships, even putting a lot of this stuff into context, thinking about sort of, like, you know, how do you measure uncertainty about relationality? How do you think about the, why the desire is unmet in certain contexts? You know, when should you ask these questions? Who should you ask these questions of? You know, all that kind of stuff. What is role assignment again?

[1:11:25](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=4285) Like all this kind of stuff is going to be specific to your context. And I want to say that I'm more than happy to have follow-up conversations with you and or folks on your team or, you know, whatever else, you know, and or, you know, I do a lot of in-person stuff too. And so anyway, thank you so much. And so we have 15 minutes, 15 minutes for Q and A. And so I look forward to it. I'm going to stop sharing my screen and yeah, so let's, let's do it. What do you got?

**Unknown speaker**

[1:11:52](https://youtu.be/pWH34ChkOck?t=4312) Thank you so much, Adam. Let me just take us off recording as promised.

* * *

Original page: https://innovate-us.org/how-and-why-to-form-new-collaborative-relationships-to-tackle-civic-challenges · Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/), as stated on innovate-us.org
