---
id: "workshop:the-future-of-work-challenges-and-opportunities-for-the-public-sector"
type: "InnovateUS workshop"
title: "The Future of Work: Challenges and Opportunities for the Public Sector"
url: "https://innovate-us.org/the-future-of-work-challenges-and-opportunities-for-the-public-sector"
date: "2023-08-24"
duration: "60 minutes"
language: "English"
instructors: ["Chike Aguh"]
recording: "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v4_VL0BBY7c"
transcript: "automatic, from the recording"
source: "InnovateUS (innovate-us.org)"
licence: "CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/), as stated on innovate-us.org"
---

# The Future of Work: Challenges and Opportunities for the Public Sector

InnovateUS workshop · 24 August 2023 · 60 minutes

Join us for a 60 minute virtual workshop with Chike Aguh, former Chief Innovation Officer at the US Department of Labor. During his time working in the Biden administration, Chike led efforts to use data, emerging technologies, and innovative practice to advance and protect American workers. In this training, Chike will discuss the problems and challenges facing us in the future of work, including emerging technologies and the legacies of industrial-era practices. This training will address the potential impact of new technologies and artificial intelligence on the workforce, as well as the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic, and will present the 5 most pressing questions associated with the future of work today. Participants will also learn about positive efforts underway to address these challenges and opportunities for the public sector to prepare for the future of work.

## Learning goals

- Learn about the potential impact of new technologies and artificial intelligence on the workforce, as well as the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic.

- Address the 5 most pressing questions associated with the future of work today.

- Learn about positive efforts underway to address these challenges and opportunities for the public sector to prepare for the future of work.

## Speakers

- **Chike Aguh**, Former Chief Innovation Officer at the US Department of Labor & Senior Fellow at The Burnes Center for Social Change

Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v4_VL0BBY7c

## Transcript

Automatic transcript of the recording: names and terms can be misheard, and the times can be a few seconds off. Each time links to that moment of the video. The transcript alone: https://innovate-us.org/the-future-of-work-challenges-and-opportunities-for-the-public-sector.txt (plain text) and https://innovate-us.org/the-future-of-work-challenges-and-opportunities-for-the-public-sector.json (every segment with its start and end second).

**Audience**

[0:01](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=1) Okay, all good. Thank you and welcome.

**Chike Aguh**

[0:05](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=5) Good afternoon, and just thank you for having me. I am going to attempt to share my screen. This is always dangerous, but hopefully this will work. And hopefully you all are seeing the beginning of a PowerPoint slide that says, The Future of Work, Challenges and Opportunities for the Public Sector. If not, I probably have reached my ability to remedy that situation.

**Audience**

[0:33](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=33) We see it.

**Chike Aguh**

[0:34](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=34) But first of all, I just want to say thank you to the Bernstein, number one for having me and number one for having this space and this conversation. I really want to thank all of you for making time. You know, I just, as Hannah said, I just exited the Biden administration at the end of April. But I started my career in local government in New York City almost 20 years ago in the administration of Michael Bloomberg. Also, a veteran of state government, actually in Massachusetts with Governor Patrick. And so, as I thought about kind of how to start with this crew, I think there's one thing to really say is, as someone who sat where you sit, it's been a tough couple years. And one of the things that I always like to start saying is thank you. And I always remember a quote from Leo Varadkar. Leo Varadkar was the Prime Minister of Ireland at the beginning of the pandemic and actually is back again as Prime Minister. And he had a quote which I've always liked and he was speaking to first responders, but I think it's actually true for you all, which is, so rarely have so many dependent on so much from so few.

[1:37](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=97) And when we think about who those so few are, they're very much you all who have kept the lights on and not just kept the lights on but moved the balls forward in your various communities. So I think it's important to say thank you because it's been a tough couple years, and sadly, likely we are going to ask more of you as a country before this is all over and define this as you will. So my hope here is to share some thoughts with you about the future of work and we're going to kind of start big with what do we mean by that, and then talk about really the impacts on the economy and then talking about really ending the conversation and hopefully it'll be a jump off for questions from you. So what does that mean for those of us who lead in the public sector, as how we help people that we serve, but also help our own organizations deal with these changes and challenges. And so, I'm hoping this works. There we go. We're going to frame the challenge. I have a case, I have two cases I always walk through, we'll talk about what is the future of work. I'll talk about autonomous cars, I'll talk about loan officers, two very different professions but actually detail the parts of the challenge.

[2:39](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=159) What is the work of the future let's talk about what that means. I have kind of five questions that I really said anyone who's talking about the future of work needs to tackle and we'll walk through those and what those mean. And then lastly, what are the implications for those of us who work in the public space who lead in the public space. And my hope is I'll be able to shut my mouth after that so that we can have a conversation and really hear from the billions of you all. So, when we talk about the future of work. What is it that we mean and people say a lot of people use them as for a lot of different stuff is a remote work is a hybrid. Is it out there technology how technology change the economy is a bunch of other things. Let me talk about what I mean, when I talk about the future of work. And to illustrate this. I want to use two very different things happening in the economy. One trend that we hear about with the future of work is that with all these new technologies from generative AI everything else that a bunch of jobs are going to go away. And I'll talk about some of the data behind that but here's the example here's the example that I use it illustrates that trend autonomous vehicles, depending on who you talk to in industry autonomous vehicles will be on the road and mass between 2030 and 2040 some folks who are less optimistic will say it's 2050 before these are really but at some point there in probably our lifetimes, there will be autonomous vehicles on the road, doing things like public transit, like commercial trucking and actually potentially moving us from place to place, we all may own one one one day, it would be the average American spends almost 300 hours a year commuting I know I'm one of those I'm from Maryland in the DC area I'm sure those of you who are in Boston or any other big city or if you're in a rural place you spent a lot of that time.

[4:23](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=263) 94% of accidents are due to human error. So if you look at the data autonomous vehicles will add anywhere from 800 million billion to $1 trillion in economic benefits the US economy. That's the upside. The downside is that driving a vehicle is the most commonly held profession by an American man. There are more people who drive vehicles for a living than our teachers. And what happens to those people when these trends we're talking about comes into come comes into full relief. So there's that first trend that many of us have heard about which is some new technologies are coming that are going to obviate the need for certain jobs that we all know today they're really ubiquitous. So we've all had that conversation. There's another conversation that we also need to have which is, there will be jobs that are irrevocably changed by these technologies, the job will still exist, but the but the people who can do the job before unless they get very new skills will be able to do the job now. And the example that I always give is the loan officer so if I were in a room with all of you.

[5:28](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=328) I would usually I actually did this in England very recently. I said, how many of you have gotten alone in the last two or three years. We usually have to raise their hands, and I'll say, let me describe to you what likely happened at some point you went into an office, and you brought a bunch of papers, you sat down with a person. You filled out some forms. And then at some point that person left the room and they came back and they told you if you got the loan or not. And you asked them a question. What do you think that person did when they left the room, and I get all types of different answers some people say, oh they talked to their supervisor oh they looked at my paperwork. And at some point, someone will say a variant of this. They asked the computer. And I finally say yes. Yes, they asked the computer. When I was a kid, I'm an 80s kid. My wife and I are about to turn 40. We went to go get a loan they went into a bank, and they went and they went to go meet with a guy usually a guy. They brought all their papers, and the job of the loan officer in the 80s.

[6:35](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=395) The rest of my life was to actually make the call about whether you got the load or not. They look at your stuff they look they see if they like to you they would make a call about whether they believe you can actually pay it back, and then give them the loan or not. Today, that function that actuarial function is made by a multivariate regression algorithm. In fact, in most institutions that give out loans, if a human being wants to reserve the loan they need to get supervisor approval. But there are still loan officers today. I mean, if you want to go lease a car you want to go look you get to get a car loan so on and so forth. But the job is not very different. It's not about being an actuary, the computer does that in fact, if you look at the data, the computers, depending on how you look at it actually predicts a false better than human beings ever did. But their job now is to get you to come in the door. Their job is to once they hopefully give you a loan, get you to come back for more tell your friends, their job now is customer acquisition and account management for any of you who have ever done sales, very different from what they did before loan officer jobs still exists, but the guy who did in the 80s, probably is not the same person who's who's going to do it in 2023, who makes sure that people can make that transition.

[7:44](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=464) So when we talk about the future of work. This is what we're talking about. There are going to be some jobs that are going to go away. Because of new of new technologies, they're pretty around what those are but that some of that will happen. But then there are a bunch of jobs probably more jobs that will just be that will be very different. And the question is, who's going to make sure that people who do those jobs before can do them now. And if you think about your own organizations, I would think about that question. The jobs that go away and the jobs that are changed. And just to put some rigor on that. And here's some additional information, the amount of jobs that require their required digital skills from 2000 to now, it was 5% in 20 into the year 2000 and now 23% that number is probably actually higher now these numbers are slightly pre pandemic. Similarly, the decrease in jobs requiring few a few amount of digital skills meeting in 2056% of jobs didn't require many digital skills, that number now is 30%. In fact, I again if I were to take that number today, I am pretty sure it is lower than that.

[8:54](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=534) To put numbers on what I talked about McKinsey and company, this is actually probably late 2018 predicted that 33% of jobs can be automated fully by 20 by 2030. But this other thing which is 60% of jobs by 2030 have a third of their tasks that can be automated meaning the job still exists, but a third of those jobs can be done by machines. Now if you were doing one of those jobs and what you were really good at was the part that machines can do that should make you nervous. Because what you now need to get good at is that other two thirds of that job so again, these are the two sides of this future of work challenge that we are talking about. If you look at the debate on the future of work. There's kind of two schools of thought there, there's one thought that there's one side which is what I call the techno optimists, who have said look we've seen this before, with the industrial revolution with the service economy, more jobs were created our job now is to make sure that the people can do the new jobs, the example that's always given, which is actually a good example is the ATM, the ATM came around late 70s early 80s, and the prediction was this is going to wipe out the retail banking industry.

[10:14](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=614) If any of you have gone to a bank branch recently that's not the case they're still bank tellers they do different things. In fact, to be honest, it's actually more value adding so human beings can do, but it's an ATM actually read them up to do more value add tasks, whether it be from loans that we set a bank account to oh my god someone stole my identity and I need to get my bank account sorted out. So there's that school of thought. We're going to create enough jobs to get the full employment in the economy and we just got to make sure that we transition people well. There are the more techno pessimists who say no this is different. This is different. The speed of the change is faster than anything that we've ever seen. And we've never seen technologies take on such big swaths of the economy, and particularly we've never seen these technologies step into things that we historically consider white collar industry so for example, I'll use an example from, I just met a small business person here in Prince George's County which is where I'm from in Maryland.

[11:22](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=682) They are a 10 person small business, and they need to create an employee manual because I look I gotta have rules. This is what they would have done 10 years ago they would have hired someone to go hey tell me just crowdsource this put you know put it together I'll pay you per hour. This time they did not do that. They went to chat GPT and said, write me an employee regulation manual for my business here's what I do, and they got one. And they're like, it wasn't perfect I had to go back and change it, but I paid zero for that versus probably the hundreds of thousand dollars that would pay to a human being to go write that for me. We never have these types of jobs we never thought were vulnerable to these types of technologies but now, whether it be lawyers, even entry level coders. In the new in the new no code movement are under a pressure that we've never seen before. When I usually talk about this slide I say they're both right. And to be, and to be honest, or we can order be more accurate, we don't know who's right.

[12:26](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=746) But to be really honest, there are things that we can see that absolutely going to have an economic benefit and create jobs we have to make sure that people can transition into them. We also have to be frank that these technologies are changing jobs faster than we've ever seen. And we just can't assume that it's going to happen by itself and what I say is the answer to these questions is really going to depend on us as a country and particularly those in the public sector we're trying to solve this on behalf of citizens who work in the economy every single day. If this is going to turn out the way that we want it to, you know, my son is six my daughter is a year and a half and if they're going to have as good a quality of life as hopefully we've had. It's going to require us to do some things now, and not just have believe that this will take care of itself. So, if we're going to talk about how we tackle this challenge. And again we're starting at the top of the funnel we're kind of coming down. I say they're really five questions that you that you really got to tackle and think through and I'll talk about each of them.

[13:26](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=806) I'll say them all and then I'll talk about kind of how they show up in the economy and how I tried to think about them. The first question is where are the current and future jobs on the left side of the screen and the way I said is, what is the work of the future. This is really, really, this is really important whether you're in an organization whether you're in an economy or you're you're leaving a country. What is the actual work of the future for those of us who've worked in municipal government I remember in the late 2000s, every city that you can think of was saying, I'm going to be the next Silicon Valley I worked in New York City so we had like we And I would meet cities from the Midwest like oh yeah we're gonna be the Silicon Prairie, and we're going to be. And if we're frank, and we look at the data, it didn't all turn out that way. Some people are like some people were successful but most weren't. I would argue one of the reasons they weren't successful is they weren't really precise always what jobs you going for. Okay. You, I'm from the state of Maryland, and I'll think about green jobs that's another place where you're seeing a lot of states and localities say we want to be in the lead.

[14:28](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=868) I'm from Maryland. It's sunny decently, but are we going to be the leader, like Arizona and solar, no, we're not going to be. We had a lot of coastline off the eastern shore of Maryland, and off the Chesapeake Bay, our governor wants to build one quarter of us when capacity off the eastern shore of Maryland. The skills to be both decisions are very different. If you're talking about setting up and maintaining solar panels as a very different job and the folks who are going to build wind turbines that are taller than football fields. But what I say is we as people who are in organizations and who are trying to lead economies have to be really precise. In organizations, as we think about hiring, we'll talk about skills-based hiring later, one thing that I also say is when you're hiring for a job or what you think the job is going to be, most jobs require 32 separate subtasks to be done. Do you know what each of those tasks are? I will say when I was at the federal level, we would meet with companies all the time, and the amount of times I pulled people to sit, two people from the same company and asked them what skills are required to do the same job, and I got different answers, problematic, particularly if you're trying to hire good people and not just rely on, again, credentials that may or may not totally be applicable.

[15:45](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=945) But being clear on what is the work of the future, and this is a combination of being very granular about what the occupations are and then also mapping that against future trends. What is the work of the future? The second is how do you prepare the workers of the future for that work? And so some of this is about, again, tying to the first question, how are you clear about this? I think what most people know and we'll talk about this is every job has technical skills. Hey, they're just brass tacks, things that you need to know. Let's just use a person who stocks shelves at a retail store, a Target, for example. Hey, look, they got to know how to work the price gun. They have to know how to work the inventory system, so on and so forth. Those are just very tactical things. But we also know what makes someone successful in that job is when me, and usually when my wife sends me to Target to go get something, I'm super lost. I have no idea where anything is. And someone who can listen to my question, hey, I'm looking for X, and for them to be able to figure out, hey, this thing is going to be over here. If it's not there, then it's there. It's just that level of emotional intelligence, number one, to not make me feel stupid, so I come back to the store and spend more money, but also to help me satisfy my task as quickly as possible so I can get back out.

[16:54](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=1014) That is what people call soft skill, a human skill, a power skill, but it's not a technical thing. Most job training today, whether that be in a company, whether that be funded by the government, does not pay as much attention to the latter set of skills as they should. And it's important. And when we think about particularly the most underserved populations, we particularly don't pay enough attention to it. So one example of a place that really does is I think about the apprenticeship movement, which as someone who was in the Biden administration, and I heard some Boston people on here. I spent a lot of time with your former mayor over the last two and a half years, and he is a big apprenticeship believer. But there's a reason for that, which is that you get to work over a number of years alongside a master at their profession and learn not just the technical, but also those things that at times are hard to teach but are easy to see and imitate and emulate. We also need to think through the second question, new types of training. I'll use one example that I find super novel. When the pandemic started, I met a company called Tailspin. Tailspin basically helps companies use XR headsets to train their workers. And so they were working with a major insurance company that you are familiar with, that you've probably seen their commercials. And they were using VR headsets to train claims adjusters. So what they would do during the pandemic, because remember, you couldn't train in person because it was not safe, they would mail a Microsoft HoloLens headset to someone, you put it on, and all of a sudden, you're in a house that's had a fire. And there's going to be a voice walking you through how to do the investigation. And at the end of it, they're going to put you in another house, and you have to do the investigation on your own.

[18:38](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=1118) That's how they're going to assess you. Contactless. Way less person hours to do that work. But as we think about how our organizations train, as well as how we fund training across the country, are we incentivizing this? I'll tell you right now, the folks who are really doing this are the biggest companies who do this anyway. Walmart's been doing this for seven years since 2017 to train folks on customer service. I actually went to a Walmart academy once, put on a headset, and there was a customer screaming at me because I was in the bakery section, and I screwed up their birthday cake. I had misspelled their kid's name. And dealing with that in real time, it felt real to me, even though it was only a simulation. But how are we incentivizing new types of training on top of making sure that we're in some ways giving folks the most timeless skills that are going to make them successful in the job? The next question, how do the worker and the work find each other? For those of us who took economics a long time ago, we always got told about this mythical world where there was perfect information. Hey, if someone has the skills needed for a job, and an employer has that job, they're just going to find each other, and it's going to be great. All of us know that doesn't happen. All of us know that. Why? Because the majority of jobs in America, and in most places, are not filled by a job posting. I guarantee you that all of us have at one point been hired, or hired someone who knew a guy, who knew a guy, who knew a guy, who told you that there was a job available. So there's a problem with that. Number one, people hire people like themselves. And number two, it doesn't guarantee you get the best people. It just guarantees you get people that you know. And what we're seeing, again and again, is that frankly, and I saw this from big companies, I heard it, is that frankly, people have already hired all the people that they know.

[20:35](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=1235) If you want to fill these critical jobs, particularly the jobs that have come through federal investment, like the bipartisan infrastructure law, the inflation reduction that ships, you're going to have to hire people in communities that you've never seen, never met, who may have challenges that you've never dealt with. And you've got to shorten the distance. Some of that is actually, how do you go out in communities and make people aware? So I'll use an example. Again, I'm from Prince George's County, Maryland. And in my county, on the border, on the Potomac River, is the largest casino on the eastern seaboard. The MGM Grand. It's a wonderful place. You want to go see a concert, you want to go see a boxing match, it's great. They had jobs open for years, hundreds of them, in fields like CDL, driving a vehicle, food service, groundskeeping, things that pay $20 to $30 an hour, and that generally don't take more than 12 weeks to train for. But those jobs were open for years. Similarly, in my county, about a half hour from there is a community called Fairmont Heights, District Heights, Forestville, frankly, of people who desperately need work.

[21:43](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=1303) In my county, the unemployment rate is usually two points above the Maryland average. So half an hour away from this place that had jobs open, pretty easy to fill. We had a lot of people who needed work, but they couldn't find each other. Why? They didn't know. It was hard to get there because there's not great transportation between those two parts of the county. And some of them may come with barriers to employment, like some of them may have a criminal justice record. How do we remove those barriers? Because whether it's the semiconductor industry that I spent a lot of time with, or whether it's state governments around the country, or city governments who have hundreds of vacancies, we need to get these jobs filled because we can't do our work if there aren't people there to do them. So how do we make sure the worker and the work find each other? Fourth question, how do we support workers through this process? And the way I like to say it is, in America, we have, at best, we have a safety net that has a couple holes in it, in terms of our benefits and our supports. But at best, what it does is that system of benefits catches you when you fall out of the labor market and make sure you don't have an economic death, when it works well. But what we really want is we want an economic trampoline. We want something that catches you and it bounces you back into the labor market, at least as good off as you were before. And we're not quite there yet, if we're very, very candid. I worked on unemployment insurance at the Department of Labor for two and a half years. That was actually what the majority of my time was. And I see the system at its best. It helped a lot of people stay in their homes, literally, during the pandemic. I also watched people whom it didn't help get out of long-term unemployment. And we've got to think about that. And the way I like to say it is, how do we make this a one-stop shop of economic opportunity? I usually, and I'm a little cheeky here when I say this, but what Amazon is really good at making it seamless and easy for me to buy a bunch of things I don't need. Whereas for benefits that keep people in their homes, that keep a roof over their heads, that keep their kids fed, that help make sure that they can get to work or have work at all, we make it as hard as possible. You have the wrong form today. I need you to come back

[23:48](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=1428) tomorrow. Shoot, I took a day off work for this. Oh, sorry. Or, ah, ah, this first form you drop off here, but I need you to go across town on the bus that might not be on time to go drop off the other form. And so if we could think of the perfect system, and I'll use unemployment insurance just as a start of that, even though you can start in many different places. It's kind of like streets and ladders. Imagine you get unemployed, or you decide you want to get a better job. Ideally, you would go into the unemployment office. You would apply for benefits if you are so eligible. You would get those benefits, hopefully super quickly. In the federal government, we were setting goals of hopefully giving benefits out to people in less than seven days. Ideally, being able to apply in less than a half hour. Ideally, also, we would tell you, by the way, you know you're eligible for all this other stuff, too. We don't need you to sign new forms. Hey, you can get TANF. You can get SNAP. Hey, you want to go back to school? Hey, we can help you do the FAFSA so you can get a Pell to help support that. Ideally, the same shop.

[24:49](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=1489) Amazon's great at that. I buy one thing, it tells me eight other things that people bought that may be related, may not be, but it's more likely to make me spend money, but they don't make me go look for it. Hey, what do you think you want to do next? Hey, we have a quick assessment for you. Let me tell you what's hiring in the local area. Let me tell you now proven training programs that you could take to go get there. Hey, or hey, you actually already have the skills. This is great. Let's connect you directly to HR. Imagine if that was the system that people had when they followed the labor market versus what we make them do now. Not just how much more dignified would that be for individuals, but also, frankly, we'd have a lot less jobs open. Last time I checked, we had anywhere from eight to 10 million open jobs in this country, most of them actually with family sustaining wages. That's the system that we need. So as we think about whether it be in our organizations and our agencies or in the country, how are we supporting people through that process? Let me say one last one, and this is a question I didn't think as much about until I got really to the Department of Labor. I always worked on the workforce development side of what labor does, and I really got to work with the folks who do like worker protection. So if we have anyone from a labor agency who works in a wage and hour division or an OSHA, how do we make sure that workers are protected, dignified, and advancing once they're on the job? How do we make sure people aren't being discriminated against because of who they are, what they look like, or who they love? How do we make sure that people are paid what they need to be paid to take care of their family? How do we make sure that people are not just in a dead-end job and actually advancing in their career if they so choose? I say that because it's the right thing to do, but also, we are in what someone once termed in the Financial Times a forever tight labor market, meaning, depending on how you look at the data, at best, the American workforce is growing very slowly. At worst, it's shrinking, but what it means is we don't, there aren't just tons of workers for you to go after. This is a, if the buyers aren't employers and the

[26:51](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=1611) sellers are workers, it's a seller's market right now, and if you want your jobs filled, it's not just about how much you pay, it's about is this a job that someone wants to be in because they have choices? And we really think about the public sector, we've really got to think about this from a job quality perspective and a career advancement perspective. How do we make this a job that people want to do when they have choices? Because sadly, because of the amazing, not sadly, but the knowledge that you all have, many of you, sadly, could go out, take those same skills, and go somewhere else and actually make more money. I don't want any of you to do that because we need you in the service of your locality, your state, and your country, but we've got to think through, really, for young people starting their careers, for mid-career professionals, for folks who are senior, how do we make sure that this is a job that they want to stay in and it's a quality job that, again, fills them, dignifies them, and gives them a path where they say they want to be? So, as we think about these five questions, think about them, again, from the micro of your organization, but to the macro of the country. So, a couple of lessons that I think I've learned looking at data from this. One is something that we've already said, is this rise of what we call hybrid jobs. Hybrid jobs are basically jobs, we at times think about jobs on a spectrum. There are what I call the white coat jobs, where it's all numbers, it's STEM, they don't talk to people, they just sit in front of a computer or a blackboard, they just do numbers all day. And then there's this other end of jobs, which is all about talking to people and leading and communication. And I think for those of us who've worked, we know that's not how it works.

[28:26](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=1706) We know that the most successful people, the most important jobs require both, these hybrid jobs. And what you see here, just to delineate this, is if you look at the jobs that are growing the most, is the jobs that require both of these things. A lot of them are in the technology space. And we don't think of technology jobs as jobs that require both sides of our brains, but they do. If you think about a new job that's coming up because of generative AI, prompt engineering. All a prompt engineer is, is someone who's really good at writing the prompt that goes in the box that tells the AI what to do. It's actually not really an engineering job at all. It's actually someone, you actually need someone who's really good at language to make that happen. Because the technical side, the AI, frankly, is becoming really good at doing. So that's just one lesson learned. A couple of things that I'm going to say about the public sector and what I think those of us who try to lead here need to think about. And I'm going to go clockwise, starting in the upper left. The first thing, we got to invest in skills-based hiring. We got to hire based off degree, off skills, not pedigree. You see in my home state of Maryland, our previous governor, Governor Hogan, eliminated college degree requirements for, I want to say, 40% to 50% of Maryland state jobs. You see a number of other states go that way. I want to be very clear, the college degree is not meaningless. But what this does say is, if I'm going to require a college degree, I should think about it for college.

[30:00](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=1800) What are the things that college degrees really require to do the job well? Really, really important. Caveat that I say, not caveat, but a thing to think about. There's a reason that college degrees became so popular. One, there weren't that many of them for most of the 20th century, 21st century. And secondly, they were a really easy way to separate people. When I used to work at a company called the Advisory Board, we got 50,000 resumes a year. Really easy way to sift through them, who has a college degree and who doesn't. If it wasn't totally germane, if you're going to remove the college degree requirement, or at least the arbitrary college degree requirement, you have to think through, how else am I going to choose between people that is quick and efficient as what I just did? And this is why I say understanding the skills and having quick ways to assess those skills are really, really important. And so that's a big challenge. I'm happy to talk through some models of what that can look like.

[31:02](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=1862) Let's go to the upper right, which, as I say, like teams are not born, great teams are not born, they are made. One of the things where I think the public sector is way behind the private sector is we invest too little in the professional career development of our people. When I was working in a New York City government way back when, and it was New York City, so it's always particular, there was a bit of a sink or swim mentality. Hey, look, the smart phones are going to figure it out and the ones who can't, well, they have something else to do. What we know is each of us who's been successful in particularly in these public jobs, someone took us aside, someone invested in us. And sometimes that was because we were smart and ambitious and we got the right mentors because we sought them out. But a lot of us just got lucky. I know I was. And so how do we make sure that we're not just depending on luck to get people developed, but how we're actually investing in people in ways that are tied to their jobs, they're cohort based, people are learning together.

[32:06](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=1926) So, and that we're not just teaching them the nuts and bolts of how things have been done, we're bringing in trends and innovations from outside of government around technology and innovation, as well as learnings from other leadership styles and schools like lean, agile, I'll talk about the team of teams methodology a little later. This is not a luxury anymore. This is table stakes, because remember, the people that you are you have in your organization now and the people that you're going to hire, they can go work somewhere else that has that stuff. So, particularly if you don't necessarily have the fiscal levers to pay them like what they will make in the private sector, you've got to give them something else. So you've got to basically kind of let them know hey you're going to leave more valuable and more skilled and you came to do that you've got to invest in their development and this is the thing that as someone who's been in local state and other federal government for government probably I think is ahead of the curve here but still has a long way to go we have to invest in our people in ways that are intentional and meaningful. If I go down to the lower right leverage new technologies, don't run from.

[33:14](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=1994) If I think about the Department of Labor and I got and I was my honor to work for first Marty Walsh, again for the for the Bostonians, and then a Julie Suze now the acting secretary was actually my direct boss. One of the things that we did during that time was enlisting to our workers really those were frontline, we asked them like what are you just wasn't that would make your life a lot easier, and something we heard a lot was shoot. I take a lot of phone calls from people who need help from us. And I answered the same question over and over again. I wish there was a way I could take that off my plate so that I could do the more valuable work that really requires my brain and so what do we do. We started, we started, you know, robotic process automation and credit chatbots to answer specific questions about specific things. So instead of calling the hotline or coming to the office, or going to the regional office and being mad we have but we had we had over 200 regional offices across the country that people walked into all the time with tons of questions. We have we have this chatbot that you can use that that will answer most of the kind of those low level questions that make up majority of inquiries. That's saving hundreds of thousands of man hours across that organization now.

[34:19](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=2059) My advice is pilot and scale these relentlessly. Learn the technologies don't run from them. And the question is what are my people doing right now. That is not value add not the best use of them and how do I slide in technology to that place to free them up one. At times fear you'll hear particularly for those of us who work in where we have public sector unions is at times you'll feel like oh shoot I don't want to send a message I'm trying to automate these people out of existence. You're not going to automate anyone out of existence but you're going to take that person and use their time better. Anytime that person is doing something that a machine can do is wasted time that is wasted tax dollars, and that is a wasted bit of value for the citizens that you all serve. Let me say the last piece. And I imagine when a lot of you have talked about future of work over the last three years you've been talking about remote hybrid, all that who's working from home who's. I'll state my piece, I believe people should be in person to do the things that only needs to be done in person. That's what that's my belief.

[35:26](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=2126) I'm not saying that remote work is everything but there's an assumption that everything's got to be in the office because that's the only way I know that people are working. If the only way that you know people are working is because you're looking over their shoulder you have to question your own leadership ability as a manager. And to be honest, in every sector, too many managers have relied on, I'm going to look over your shoulder to see if you're actually getting the job done. Are you clear on the strategy of the organization, of the metrics of success. Okay, if you are clear, are your people clear, have you told them. Do they know what that looks like every day, every week, every month, every quarter, every year. Do they know what happens if you don't meet those targets. Do they know their own role in meeting those targets. I'm gonna be honest, if you have those questions answered, whether people are at home, whether they're in person, becomes less relevant. But I, but as I said before, when you're in person, you can use being in person to cover up bad management.

[36:29](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=2189) When we, I like to say I believe a lot of bad managers were exposed when we went remote. And also I think some great leaders were revealed when we went remote. And as I always say, look, I worked in the, in the Department of Labor, if you had ever told me the Department of Labor, the federal government would go remote, the Department of Labor went remote in like 30 days. And if you've ever worked in the US Department of Labor, it is not an organization that you would have thought way back when, as much as I love it, that you would have thought could do that that quickly, but it did. And if you looked at the KPIs, they didn't move that much in terms of productivity going down. So questioning the wrong question is should we be in person or should we be remote. And again, remember, there are people who have choices, who can go to the places that can have a type of work that works with their lives. So what I would encourage you to think of is, where are we going, how do I know I got there, how do I know I'm going in the right direction, and how do I make sure all my people know.

[37:31](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=2251) I have a few other slides, I'm not going to go through them, I'm just going to give one anecdote and then I'm going to be quiet and love to take questions. I used to work for General Stan McChrystal in the private sector and one of the great leader and someone who I count as a mentor. There's a story that he tells a lot that I think really captures this last point. In 1862, John F. Kennedy went to NASA, he went to Cape Canaveral, and he walked in, and he sees a man mopping the floor. And he goes up to the man and he says, Sir, what is it that you do here? And the man looks up, and he says, I'm putting a man on the moon, Mr. President. I always have found that anecdote powerful for a couple of reasons. One, the janitor looked up at the President of the United States and was able to say I'm putting a man on the moon. That's what he said. What I also find powerful is what he was doing. He wasn't trying to be the air traffic controller. He wasn't trying to be the rocket scientist designing the rocket. He wasn't trying to be the astronaut flying the rocket. He wasn't trying to be in mission control controlling things.

[38:36](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=2316) He was mopping the floor because he said my job is to keep this floor clean so that those people can get to where they need to get this guy on the moon. What I always would ask managers when I told that story is, if I pulled a random person from your organization right now and I asked them what is it that you do here, what would they say? All the managers are like, oh, my God, please don't do that. Because if we're honest, most of us as leaders are not as clear as we would like to be on what our organizations need to do. And you can't get to a world that is hybrid. And I'll be honest, we will never go back to five days a week. It will not happen. Anyone who believes that, maybe you're like one of those states like Maryland that legalized recreational cannabis. Maybe that allows you to believe that, but we're not going back to that. You are going to live in a hybrid world and it requires good leadership and it requires you not to have to rely on physical proximity to overcome a lack of strategy. And again, the people who you want to keep, they have choices, and they can go places that are clear, that do have a form factor that meets the needs of their lives and are giving them a quality of life that makes it good for them now but also for them in the future.

[39:45](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=2385) So, I see all of these as challenges but also opportunities, because I also feel like in this time people are looking for purpose, people are looking for cross sector experiences. And I'll tell you as someone who worked on unemployment insurance for the last two and a half years, we hired an amazing team of technologists at the Department of Labor to help work on this with states across the country. In fact, some of the states who are represented on this call. We have people who turned down jobs at Google, at NVIDIA, at Microsoft to come work with us. Why? Because they said, look, I may not be in government the whole time but I want to do something right now that matters. And trust me, we're not paying them what Google could pay, we're not paying them what Microsoft could pay them, but we gave them a purpose. And we gave them a set of experiences that they're going to take with them. So, that's the type of opportunities that are available if we can grab this moment. Hannah, I'm going to get off my soapbox and be quiet now. I would love to dialogue with the rest of you. Thank you so much for your time and your attention.

**Audience**

[40:43](https://youtu.be/v4_VL0BBY7c?t=2443) Thank you so much, Chike. That was fantastic. Before we go to Q&A, I'm just going to use this chance to plug our future workshops because starting in September, we'll have one workshop a week through December. And Chike was speaking about unemployment modernization. We have one in mid-September presented by the New Jersey Office of Unemployment Modernization and they went through a whole process. Oh good, good. Yeah, and so that'll be a hands-on workshop for states. On September 7, we also have a special workshop with Jennifer Polka who just released Recoding America. And Ezra Klein has called it one of the best policy books of the year. So, that'll be a fun conversation with Steve Kadish, also from Massachusetts. I've put the link in the chat to sign up for workshops and you can sign up for as many as you like. I'm going to stop this recording now.

* * *

Original page: https://innovate-us.org/the-future-of-work-challenges-and-opportunities-for-the-public-sector · Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/), as stated on innovate-us.org
