---
id: "workshop:what-now-how-the-role-of-public-servant-leader"
type: "InnovateUS workshop"
title: "What now? How the role of Public Servant Leader is Evolving Post Covid and the Digital Revolution"
url: "https://innovate-us.org/what-now-how-the-role-of-public-servant-leader"
date: "2022-01-25"
language: "English"
instructors: ["Alexis Bonnell"]
recording: "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ej2Gi3dYsw"
transcript: "automatic, from the recording"
source: "InnovateUS (innovate-us.org)"
licence: "CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/), as stated on innovate-us.org"
---

# What now? How the role of Public Servant Leader is Evolving Post Covid and the Digital Revolution

InnovateUS workshop · 25 January 2022

Join us to hear from Alexis Bonnell, a long-time public servant, now the Emerging Technology Evangelist at Google for Public service, as she takes almost 2 years of helping Public Servant leaders evolve during COVID and shares what she has learned, the trends she is seeing, and how public service will be changed forever.

## Learning goals

- Explore how public servants are navigating this new "Living System Leadership" paradigm
- Identify emerging trends and learn to adapt in a changing world

## Speakers

- **Alexis Bonnell**, Former Head of Innovation, USAID

Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ej2Gi3dYsw

## Transcript

Automatic transcript of the recording: names and terms can be misheard, and the times can be a few seconds off. Each time links to that moment of the video. The transcript alone: https://innovate-us.org/what-now-how-the-role-of-public-servant-leader.txt (plain text) and https://innovate-us.org/what-now-how-the-role-of-public-servant-leader.json (every segment with its start and end second).

**Alexis Bonnell**

[0:01](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=1) My name is Alexis Bonnell. And as I got to explain to one of your colleagues earlier on, I'm here because I've got this really weird, maybe opportunity to share with you. And that is like, like many of you, I was a public servant, both at the state level, but then more recently federal for more than 20 years. And it was really interesting, because in that time, I had some of the best jobs in public service you can have, including finishing as being one of the Chief Innovation Officers at a federal agency. And there were still things that I really wanted to learn, and I really wanted to understand. And so I came to Google about a year and a half ago, really to learn a couple of things, or just expand my thinking. One was around technology. To be honest, I wanted to know what was possible, what wasn't possible, what was kind of hype, and what was real, right? And I know on the call today, we have some folks that are in technology, maybe some folks that aren't. So we're going to try to straddle that a little bit. But the second thing, and the one that we probably really focus on today, is this idea that as I was trying to help my organization and my fellow staff and others navigate innovation, it was a lot about navigating change.

[1:18](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=78) And most importantly, it was a lot about culture. So learning and thinking a lot about leadership. And then finally, how we can be really, really customer focused. So I wanted to come to Google and understand, how do you make something that a billion people like to use? Those are all really important to me, because I plan on coming back to public service. So really, my goal today is sharing with you is over the past two years, no surprise to any of you, right? Things are crazy. Things have changed. Things are really interesting. But there have been a number of public servant leaders that I've gotten to work with and support. As I mentioned, maybe that was reimagining Department of Motor Vehicles and a digital FH. Maybe it was looking at how we bring health equity data, or we might use new technologies to track wildlife or other things. You know, as I looked at that, what I saw is that the really successful public servants who are navigating, you know, kind of this time of change had some really interesting similarities that we started to think about as this concept of living system leaders.

[2:22](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=142) So my goal today is really to share with you what we're seeing in these kind of behaviors and what we call living system leadership. What might make a living system leader different than someone who isn't, or maybe who doesn't have that same type of mindset? And it was really interesting to us because we love to study and we love to look at, you know, leader effectiveness, staff satisfaction, how you really create a innovative, inclusive, and impactful organization. With that being said, please continue to jump in the chat, ask your questions, feel free to, you know, to jump in if you have a particular question. After this, the team at GovLab will send you a survey so you can tell them like, yay or nay on this training. But most importantly, what I really want you to do is I know you are sitting at your desk right now. You are probably just coming off a call, going on to another business call. But really, this is a moment for us to sit back and to kind of take the luxury of really thinking at a meta level, right?

[3:28](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=208) Really thinking about what's happening in the world, what that means for us as leaders. And I ask you to give yourself a little bit of that time, right? Because you probably don't have the opportunity to do that as much as you want, as you need to. And so this is one of those little moments of luxury. So I hope you come on this journey with me. And now I'm trying to advance. Ah, perfect. Okay. So as I mentioned, my name's Alexis Bonnell. I'm at Google. Now, some of you may have specific technology questions or something about Google doesn't work and is broken, and that's what you really want out of this call from the Google lady. And I put my email there. Any questions you have on living system leadership or anything else Google after this, please feel free to email me. I'm happy to help you. But one of the things I want to start out with is this quote from Eric Schmidt, which I think is really interesting. And that is, you know, we're all thinking about how we can be more innovative, right? How we can find that right type of evolution for the mission that we're engaged in.

[4:29](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=269) And one of the things I loved about this, because it really hit home for me, is that really a lot about getting leadership right is about getting the culture right. And in this case, in talking about innovation, you know, the story hasn't changed. It's always been that person, that small team of people who may not be understood by the people around them, but especially their executives. And I'm sure for many of you, if you've had those moments in leadership where you have a vision, you want to bring change, those types of elements, but people just aren't getting it, aren't connecting with it. And that was something that I think a lot of public servants were able to actually really expand and exercise over the last two years. And so this type of, you know, pandemic pressure brought both a lot of chaos, a lot of pressure, a lot of headache, but also a lot of really interesting opportunity and stimulus to change and think about how we do things differently. So the first thing I want to do for all of us is give ourselves a moment of empathy and grace, meaning that I know what it's like as a public servant to not be understood, to not be appreciated, to have people not understand why their tax money is going to the thing that it is that I'm doing.

[5:46](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=346) You know, and sometimes we don't understand things back, right? And it's just frankly been a crazy two years, right? So giving ourselves a moment of empathy and to really understand and appreciate that. So to that point, you know, what I would love is if someone wants to jump in verbally or put in that, in that chat, you know, please let, you know, let me know and share with others. What are the types of things that you're seeing has changed? What are those things that, you know, have been different and or what do you think is going to stay the same or snap back? Anyone have any thoughts on that? I am. I know you always have a thought. I'm going to go to you first.

**Audience**

[6:32](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=392) Yeah, I think that. So I was relatively new in this job but I think that it was initially it was working in sort of a crisis setting and COVID I think brought together a lot of different parts of government and made it easier to work across departments and agencies than it had been before. And I think now as time has gone on it's figuring out how to keep that momentum. More generally I think working kind of remotely in this in this new shift obviously that can make work more flexible, but it can be really challenging to figure out how to build kind of the personal connections both within my own team but then with with folks across departments and agencies so in some ways, we've been forced to work more with other folks but it's hard to actually get to know them on a personal level.

**Alexis Bonnell**

[7:16](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=436) That's so true and I love some of the things coming in on the chat, you know, Victor operations and interactions. Absolutely. You know, it's interesting I was talking to, you know, Illinois the other day and we we'd help them with a bunch of different work with unemployment insurance and it was very interesting to see this idea of how you know how they were talking to more people but maybe less face to face and just all of the ways that changed back I loved ability to ask forgiveness instead of permission right that's such an important element of pressure and of these moments of crisis or change that actually their opportunities right, but they don't always feel like it you know Michelle absolutely some change is forced some is by choice. Genevieve yep telework the new norm and that we're going to talk a little bit about what that actually looks like from living system. Yeah, Jennifer great points telework. Yeah. Okay, well I love the conversation and there's going to be some other things that I introduced as well to, to our kind of meta thinking about what has changed because sometimes it's easy to see the close the near and maybe not necessarily understand those larger change formats.

[8:27](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=507) Let's see. Alright, so one of the things how many of you, and go ahead and put in chat like you know plus one or whatever how many of you are in some type of office or situation in the last few years or now that's talking about doing transformation, digital transformation organizational transformation anyone here, like in a transformation journey. Yes, yes. Yeah, absolutely. Right. And so, you know, what's interesting about this is that transformation and being asked for transformation by leaders you know by ourselves by others is really a note to kind of recognize. That transformation is a way we navigate change right that we're kind of intentional about it. And so one of the things I want us to ask ourselves again and that kind of meta level is that if we're going through transformation, whether that's digital whether that's organizational or otherwise, should we expect to lead the same way before the transformation, as we would after the transformation. Right. And, and the question, the answer might be yes but I think it's a really interesting question to ask ourselves, I put these examples as just some of the living examples where I've been studying kind of living system leaders who are public servants in these different areas, and how they have kind of brought living systems leadership to life as they navigate transformation or change.

[9:48](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=588) So to back up I you know we outlined a whole bunch of interesting elements of change. But you know here's some other really big ones that you know are important obviously huge shifting societal norms right customers being more empowered expectation have more equity more inclusion. Obviously the what they call the big quit right or the great resignation and we'll talk a little bit about that. And really what it is stimulating and people where their minds are going that might be different what that means for as a leader, really importantly I think we're going to have some empathy for incredibly shortening timeframes right y'all are being asked to make like real time policy changes doing all you know like in like such compressed time, then maybe you ever had before right and that's actually really important to ask ourselves, is that time compression, actually going to change at the end of this, and I think there's a lot of public servants, you know, have a hypothesis that it may, you know, may stretch a little bit but actually this idea of rapid faster pace, you know is is probably going to be likely.

[10:55](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=655) The other one we're seeing a lot is this desire to shift to learning and being an adaptive organization. One of the things that maybe you know of course I'm Google so I got to go there. But actually if you think about the technology, just the number of satellites, the ability to you know to use cloud connectivity, but I want us to think about something for a minute, and I want us to think about it COVID had happened. Our experience of it would be dramatically different. We wouldn't be able to share data, the way we did internationally and globally around coven like we did we wouldn't even be able to have things like curbside. Right. I mean imagine Hello people know curbside during coven like what would have happened right so just taking a moment to recognize you know what it is that technology but more importantly, the tidal wave the tsunami of information, right and have data that has started to kind of come into our lives as public servants. I think there's also this expectation of government you know to go from being reactive to proactive, and that's really hard.

[11:58](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=718) The fact that again as I mentioned information is more available to people than ever before, you know shifting customer expectations and a really interesting one at the end and this is one that I've seen a lot of living system leaders kind of really bring up and that is time poverty, meaning that you know really asking, how is it that we do our work or engage our customer or constituent you know however, however, it makes sense for you. And actually, are we contributing to time poverty, meaning how much of their time are we taking versus how much of work our time, we should and so this is a, I put this up because this is one of the things I think you're going to hear a lot about when it comes to this idea of efficiency and public servants, and so and but but I highlighted because it's a it's a pressure right. So the other thing I wanted to kind of root us in is, you know, the fact that what we're facing is the fact that changes both exponential, but also happening exponentially faster, right so if we look at these different revolutions the first industrial revolution, the second etc what you'll see at the top and read, it's kind of an ever shortening amount of time, right that that change happens in, and so for those of us and I am one of those who wants to say like it'll all go back to normal afterward like it'll snap like I call that the snapback philosophy like it'll just snap back right like it'll be normal we'll just get rid of all these things like no one needs to telework after that.

[13:23](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=803) And that's just not true but what I wanted to point out with the slide is that it's not true not only because people get used to things right and want to continue the things that they like but it's, it's also not true because of this exponential, you know, change that you know humanity is is navigating. So, in order to drive that home this is a little scary but I want you to look at this thing on the right and if you can read it hopefully you can, you will just see a non stop proliferation of incredible amounts of technologies advancements etc. So yes, these might not seem relevant to what we do right but what I want you to really take in mind is it's it's humans need to discover right to apply these discoveries but most importantly, as public servants, we have to navigate I'm still saying weeks I'm coming back y'all I'm not saying a Google forever I'm coming back to public service I'm going to use we, you know, as public servants, we have to navigate how to incorporate these changes into our nation into our communities right and so while we sometimes keep it at a distance this idea of how we navigate and incorporate and lead change is really critical.

[14:33](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=873) So, to touch on it really briefly because I think it's so important. And again, please, you know, put in comments questions and Kate is going to be good about calling out if there's a question we should specifically, you know, stop and talk about. So there are a couple interesting things about you know the big quit or the great resignation, I think the first is, and this is really important when you look at past trend data is it actually it's employees between the age of 30 and 45 that have the So, I'm going to talk about a number of resignations. A lot of people thought it was going to be younger age range or older age range, but actually it's in the middle. And here are a couple of reasons of why people are citing that. And the reason I highlight this again is because, you know, number one, we're all people. We're all in the workplace together. Some of us are, you know, leaders, senior leaders, but like, this is a people issue, right? So, you know, we really have to ask ourselves when we think about leadership as a topic, how are we navigating, you know, how toxic or unhealthy is our culture? You know, one of the reasons people are leaving is, you know, the signaling about job and security reorganization. And what's interesting is that there's some new research that people, a lot of people who left perceived job insecurity that actually wasn't there, right? Because their leaders weren't communicating with them effectively. Failure to recognize performance, obviously poor response to COVID-19. Oh, thanks, Beth. And Beth's putting in links and tidbits in the chat as well. But what's really important, and I want you to pay attention to it, is number five. And that is that people felt are looking for free agency. And what's interesting about this, I want you to take a moment and recognize that this last reason is actually a form of optimism, right? It's actually not negative-based transition. It's optimism-based transition because they believe, and hopefully, you know, we all believe like they deserve better.

[16:30](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=990) And so the question is, what is better, right? And that's where we get to this idea of oftentimes what we see better, what we see people going to are organizations or leaders that navigate and create cultures that really reflect living system leadership. So we'll go on a little bit more about that. So what is living system leadership? What are some of these principles? And I'm going to be very transparent with y'all. We are learning and like developing and co-creating this as we go. So we are working with, you know, whether it is insights from, you know, folks on the call today, you know, states, internationally, and kind of really saying what is working in this new world. So this is an ever-expanding set, but here are kind of 10 things that people really have called out are true principles of living system leadership. Number one, expecting change and planning for it, and try to put under and kind of parentheses what that actually looks like or how you might actually action that. So for example, if you're someone who expects change, you're going to run scenarios. You're going to ask what if. You're going to do exercises like post-mortem just to create the space, right, to think about change and not to think about it in a we have to do it or it's overwhelming, but kind of in that more curious way. Number two, developing comfort and ambiguity while seeking insight, right, being able to know that it's okay to not have the perfect answer while you seek insight. Constant collaboration, seeking evolution, but it's not about change for change's sake, and that's actually really important, right, because I think a lot of times when we talk about change, people assume, oh, you know, this is just change for change's sake, and the whole point of living systems leadership is to know specifically what it is that you're trying to evolve, what you're trying to create space for. The fifth is play nicely with others. So I'm sure this never happens in any of your organizations. I have to say, though, a few times when I was a public servant,

[18:32](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=1112) you know, there can be a little passive aggressiveness. There can be a little bit of like this is my camp, stay in your camp, you know, type of thing, and so, you know, I really had to evolve and change and learn to play nicely with others. Defaulting information transparency, value and fostering curiosity, we're going to talk a lot about that, but also this is a really interesting one and a really important one, probably one of the core principles of living system leadership, and that is building in generational flexibilities, and what I mean by that is not generation like baby boomer or millennial, but more generation like the person who's going to fill my shoes after me. What have I left them? Have I left them with flexibility? Have I left them with like great information? Have I left them, you know, with the ability to thrive in a world that's different from mine today? Or, for example, did I lock them into a 10-year single vendor contract and they just have to survive that, right? I'm using IT terms as an example, but it's those types of policy or purchasing or other examples that actually really come to life when you think about generational flexibilities. Nine, really important, obviously, walking the talk, and 10, and this is one that really sank in for me, is this concept of recalibrating risk. One of the things that I found, which was really interesting when I was leading the innovation work at the agency I was at, is we assumed that how we did things now was not risky and that anything that we were going to change was risky, and actually what we found as we started to change a few of the models, and I'll give you an example, often we would do very large education programs, $100 million plus contracts over five years. Then we started trying doing, you know, experimenting with 30 different methods for a year and then rolling out the one that had the highest level of impact, right, measurable evidence-driven impact, and if you think about it, the first one was actually much

[20:34](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=1234) more risky, right? We put $100 million out there and hoped after five years it would work. The second one, while we were spreading some of those funds around early on, you know, the $95 million that we ended up deploying against the solutions that we knew really worked, we actually, we were paying for results at that point because we really knew it. So I share that with you because I think thinking about this idea of what is risky and what is not is really, really important. All right, so first of all, before I move on, I'm going to ask you all, is there one here that really calls out to you that you wish, you know, you could do better or your boss could do better or that your agency could do better or one that you think you do really well? Go ahead and put that in chat. Let's see how we're stacking up here. Recalibrate risk. Nice, Bertha. Yeah, that's actually one of the most challenging ones, I think, because there's a lot of assumption. Number eight, generational flexibilities.

[21:35](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=1295) You know, Danielle, it's interesting. For me, that's the one that I think before being exposed to a lot of these great public servants, I hadn't really thought through, right? I really, like, that's one that's really powerful for me. We're calibrating risk. Eight for you as well. Yeah. So these are things that, you know, again, a lot of the others you've heard, number three, constant collaboration and humility. Yep. So these are things that I think it's just great to kind of ask ourselves, what is our relationship, you know, to some of these principles and how might you explore them? And just so you know, my goal today is nothing more than, you know, maybe you explore what number 10 is a bit more for you. Maybe you think about generational flexibilities a bit more, and we'll talk a little bit about what some of those could look like. All right. So ultimately, you know, what I want you to think about when you think about living systems leadership, and again, we're kind of morphing this, so I will probably update this based on feedback that you all give and insights you give in chat, you know, but really it fundamentally reshapes, you know, how a public servant, you know, thinks, what is a fundamental difference, but really what it does more than anything is it enables curiosity and change in kind of our inner core as a mindset, instead of necessarily defaulting to kind of protecting the status quo. And I will tell you that this was a really painful journey for me, right? I, you know, would get into different leadership positions and I would kind of get it organized and I would get it running well, and then, you know, even though I was the head of innovation, I would kind of want to protect the status quo, like we've got this, we're doing this right, like don't mess our stuff up, right? Which is pretty funny when you're with a person who's supposed to be driving change. And so I say that because I know it's just inherent, right, for us to want to be in that mindset of like, how do we, how do we maintain, you know, kind of comfort and good, you know, consistency. And in some elements of public servants, that's absolutely critical, right? But there also has to be moments in that mindset where we can shift, you know, we can switch on and we could say, how could it be a little bit better? How can I do this better? Where might other

[23:36](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=1416) ideas come from? So what I wanted to highlight and propose for you is that as I was looking at my work as a public servant, but more importantly, observing these 50 plus public servant leaders that I've gotten to watch and work with over the past two years, as they navigated huge issues and crises in this country, is that really when we step back together, when I talked with them, what they actually said is they're like, you know, I realized that right now I might be a technical leader, I might be a CIO, or I might be the head of acquisitions, or I might be this and that. But what they started to realize is that what they really were, were information stewards, right? Because as public servants, we're really being asked to take in information, you know, validate it, make sure it's relevant, make sure it's the right thing. Then we make pretty critical decisions around that, right? We're assigning resources, we're deciding who gets what, what happens to someone, right? I mean, really interesting things. And then we take in more information to observe whether those decisions, judgments, programs, etc, were effective in the way that we want them to. So what I want to highlight for you, I want to highlight this idea that ultimately, if in addition to our role as let's say a CIO, or the head of a program, like, you know, Department of Motor Vehicles, if I'm that, but I'm also an information steward, and I see Louisa, the sharing of information has been a big challenge. Yep. I mean, that idea, it's what's interesting about what you're pointing out, sorry, Chief Innovation Officer, or Information Officer, either one. What I'm pointing out, I think, you know, to your point, Louisa, about water cooler is that actually, we learn a lot informally, right? We're curious with each other in a way of human intimacy that like the water cooler brings that maybe you're not going to get remotely, right? So this idea of how curiosity is created and founded. But what I really want to, you know, drive home is this idea of no matter what we're doing, this idea of needing to be curious, right? And I will tell you, this was the number one trait that we saw when we looked

[25:38](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=1538) at super high performing public servants, and actually, leaders anywhere versus those that maybe were not as high performing. Curiosity, you know, was a big element of that. So when you think about living systems leadership, we're really founding that and this idea of being curious. So I want to juxtapose for you a little bit what we call like a legacy or maybe traditional like formalities of leadership, and maybe what living systems leadership would look like differently. So and for those of you, how many of you have actually ever heard of the strangler big principle? Put a zero in the chat if you've never heard of it. Okay, I hadn't heard about it either. And actually, a public servant explained it to me because I was asking how it was that they had taken this particular approach. This was in Hawaii, how they had taken this particular approach to a challenge in COVID. And it was really interesting because he said, I want to be a tree. And I was like, okay, I don't know what to do with being a tree. Like, please more. And you know, he said, you know, I want to be a strangler fig. And a strangler fig is a particular type of tree. And what you're seeing is that in essence, you know, they, they're kind of a, I guess, an infested tree, where they actually will attach to a different tree, you know, they kind of put roots down, you know, and over time, they use the structure of that core, right. And I want you to think about that trunk of that tree, that could be your current IT system, it could be your current policies in an area, it could be your current hiring practices.

[27:18](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=1638) And the reality is that that tree is really important, right? That trunk is really strong. It's been put there for a reason. But it doesn't mean it's the only thing that your organization can do. Oh, yeah, I love Bertha, your point on curiosity says curiosity can seem like skepticism or resistance at the steward of the information is not transparent, even defensive. Absolutely. Love that. And we'll come back to that actually in a little while. But when you think about strangler, you know, the strangler fig, what you're seeing is that you can actually build change intentionally around your core concepts, right. So what the strangler fig does is it puts down and it builds little, you know, little branches and things until as you see on the right hand side of the picture, there's actually none of the original tree left, right, this kind of all successful transformation was able to happen. But what's critical about this, and why I pointed out and I like the idea of the strangler fig as a metaphor, is that oftentimes, we think about change, like it has to rip something out, right, you have to replace it, you have to. And what's really important as humans, as we think about the fact that we have to lose, right in change. And what I love about strangler fig, or this idea of living, you know, systems thinking is that really, you can start to complement, you can start to bring in new insights, new, you know, new data, new policies, new ways of working that can work with current systems or current structures, but over time, you know, can really give you enough support and enough change and help your culture make that slow transition, you know, to kind of successfully end up in a new place. And so I just wanted to kind of highlight this as a really great example and illustrative about what change can look like. Because I think sometimes we have such negative connotations to the disruption of change, that we don't think about these elegant ways. And what I will tell you without fail is, there are a few public servants that I I've looked at, I've seen, you know, been able to help them accomplish a few really interesting things with technology. And I was like, how did you do that? How did you get them to agree to that?

[29:21](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=1761) How did you get buy-in for that? And a lot of it was this kind of slowly, slowly, let me meet the culture, let me meet the policy, let me make connections. And for those of you that are technology, you know, centered or focused, you might think about it as like, how do I bring in an API, right? Maybe I don't need to rip out the whole system, I just need to bring some information flow from somewhere else as an example. So living system leadership right now kind of has four categories, right? People, process, technology, and information. And I put this here because I really just wanted us to juxtapose. These are not, you know, the only definitions or examples, but You know, really, when we're thinking about this as leaders, there's maybe the old paradigm. So we think about people we've seen in the chat, you know, the old paradigm, everyone in the office all the time, right? And I was the first telework executive at my agency 10 years ago. And I remember talking to many managers about the fact that, you know, well, they have to be in front of me, because if they're not in front of me, how will I know what they're doing? How will I know that they're working, right? And of course, the reality is that there's a lot of other ways, you know, that maybe we manage or understand what someone's doing or performing, but that was a mindset, right? You know, now it might be limited, no one in the office, right? Very dynamic. And then long term. And this is really the goal of living systems thinking, it's actually to respect the past, right? To say, what was the way that we did something? And why we did it that way? Because you know what, like public servants are smart. They don't just usually do dumb things 10 years ago, because they wanted to do dumb things. They did it because it made sense at the time.

[30:58](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=1858) You know, and now we're confronted with change. So this question of what have we had to do, you know, to Beth's point, asking forgiveness versus permission had to make fast changes. But more importantly, our opportunity for living system leadership is to step back and ask ourselves long term, how do I want to bring this together? Right? How do I want to braid this? I have historical knowledge, I have current knowledge. What do I want to think about? What do I want to be curious about? And how do I want to be intentional about what the future looks like? So I gave you some examples here across people, process, tech, and information. And again, they're just kind of off the cuff examples. But really, that idea of being able to intentionally put yourself in the past, in the present, and in the future is a huge part of living system leadership. All right, so here's where we're going to juxtapose. And so you can kind of feel a little bit of the tension of what we might call legacy versus living systems. Now, what's really interesting about legacy, which is how most things in government companies, organizations work, is that when we look to solve problems, what we do is we take the now, right? We say, what are what am I navigating? What does my program have to do? What are the people? What's my legislation? What's my budget? What's the process, all of those things. And you know what, that makes a ton of sense, because reflecting and responding to our reality is a very natural human place to start. What becomes really interesting, though, and I'm sure many of you have seen this, is that when you only design for the moment, a few moments later, or a year later, or five years later, you find that that has kind of been trapped in a time capsule, right? So this is where the term, you know, legacy system comes from, this idea that that thing was created a while back.

[32:45](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=1965) That thing was created for good intentions, with probably the right boundaries and the right reasons. But the reality is, is that those things changed, right? And so that's where you kind of get stuck. And legacy thinking is a little bit of something that is what we call time capsule thinking. It's also, you know, the fact that people in essence are understanding to be less risk averse, right? And again, we assume that what's been done in the past is less risky than what we might do in the future, which is actually a false construct. The other thing that is really interesting is, you know, we're confronted by a lot of information, so much information that it's hard to rapidly adapt, right? And to shift programs and things like that. And most importantly, the way I think about a legacy approach is, you know, you're in that role where you want to be the orchestra conductor, you want to be kind of handed the music, this is what you play, everyone has their part, right? Like this is how it's supposed to work. And so that's not surprising, right? That's how many of us have, you know, for those of us who are MBAs or whatever, like strategy and you do this and here's, you know, it all works. And in most of the cases, you know, that's absolutely true. But the problem is, is that all of those assumptions ultimately change, right? As many of us have seen the legislation change, the tech change, the budget change, you know, something changed. And so the idea of being able to then catch up is really hard. And so when we think about living systems leadership, what we really want to think about is how do we build something that's actually intended to be able to change, right? And how do we build that in? And I like to think about it a little bit more, like we might design, let's say, more modularly, you know, we might think about kind of toolboxes instead of like, here's the hammer, we might use open frameworks or open data, or, you know, or crowdsourced insights or policies. But most importantly, it's really created with that intent to change. And this is where that idea of the generational change comes in, right? Because if

[34:45](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=2085) you put a policy in place, you know, today, that really makes it difficult for someone to do something new to adopt something new to evolve in the future, you know, that's kind of generational, what we call generational policy baggage, right, for lack of better term. So what I want you to think about with living systems leadership is it's a little bit more chaotic, it's a little bit maybe, you know, more anxiety creating for some of us, but how am I a jazz conductor, right? Like bringing in that right tool, bringing in that right beat, letting people really thrive and bring in their incredible notes to make music, instead of necessarily always being a orchestra conductor, if that makes sense. So little, little, you know, self check in really quickly for us. So how many people would say that they are an orchestra conductor? And how many people think that they're a jazz conductor? Graham, Kate, Beth, I want to see this. Let's see some honesty here. Orchestra, orchestra. Absolutely. I was definitely an orchestra conductor. Orchestra, jazz. Nice. Okay.

[35:54](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=2154) Orchestra, orchestra. Yeah. And the reality, Jeff, look at this. Okay. Awesome. Jazz with a hint of orchestra. I like it. Jazz with them will record it and then replay it, right? But that's actually the beauty of this, right? And I really appreciate your ability to kind of reflect and say, where is this mindset I'm in? You know, jazz on the side. Yeah, we like that. And you know what, that might be right. Think about that strangler fig, adding in a little bit of jazz here and there, that might be the way to start, right? A little like trombone when you don't expect it or something, you know, that might be the way, that's okay. All right. So, you know, in thinking about this and thinking about taking us from maybe being an orchestra conductor to being comfortable with some jazz notes, you know, here's a little bit of something to think about, you know, what are the types of things I might ask, you know, or I might assume if I'm, I try jazz and I move with orchestra, fair enough, right? That's, we have to have an orchestra default is public servants. Sometimes I get that, but I put this here just to kind of act like lead you through how you might confront, you know, in a legacy approach, you know, it might say like, well, what's my budget? You know, and I'm in a living, I might say, well, what am I trying to achieve? Right. Because the reality is a lot of times to be very frank about it and public servants, and I'm sure this doesn't happen to anyone else, but I was actually given more budget than I needed. And I actually wanted to put some of that budget to something else that I really believed in. Right. So you can have like both pros and cons on this, you know, like what is the process now and how does this fit into it? Right.

[37:23](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=2243) So again, that default to status quo being where we would start, you know, versus maybe if this process would change, what might it look like, et cetera, you know, and again, you know, when we think about where we start our assumptions and some of you might switch after seeing this to, you know, actually I'm more jazzed than I thought I was. Right. But, you know, something like, okay, this is going to snap back to normal. You know, if I, if I change this, I have to scrap everything and start over, or, you know, we just deployed the system. People can't handle any more change. Right. And actually, again, remember like great resignation, like people are, are, are actually optimistic, right. The ones that are moving, believe that they want something better, right. That they want something, you know, they want that type of leadership. So, you know, looking at what we might assume instead is like, my people are smart. We can adapt to this. Right. You know, I bet others have lots of insight, that idea of collaboration, right. Is one of the principles. So this is just something to kind of help you think about. And I would love, you know, you're all speed back and you're all addition to like, how might we put ourselves in that different mindset?

[38:23](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=2303) All right. And this is going to be, I put this here. I'm not going to go through it because there's a lot here, but for those of you who are technologists, there are two technology examples that will be in the deck. And, you know, we've done this with people examples. We've done this with, you know, information or process examples, but what sometimes people ask is like, okay, if I'm a living system leader, what in a short term would I do differently? Right. To be a leader. So, you know, here we think about technology, you know, for example, you might be like, we're not doing any more contracts where vendors lock us in for five years, you know, or we're going to do a tech sandbox on that first before we make a big play. Right. Or we might say, you know what, we're going to do more data containerization to give us more flexibility. So there's just a lot of different ways in the short term that you might think about that or take that kind of, or like we may use APIs. We may keep using our legacy system, but, you know, do a data lake with API. So I'll stop talking tech because I know that doesn't, you know, float everyone's boat, but I think it's important when you're thinking about, you know, living systems to think about in my space, right. Maybe it's customer experience at the DMV, you know, what is the short term thing I might do differently? And then what is a long-term thing I might do differently? So there's another slide here. We talk about like what longer term decision-making from a tech example might look like. But again, I won't go into it. Like the last one though, for example, is, you know, like prepare for data death. Like what happens if all your data went away? Like, you know, just that kind of what-if scenario plane, et cetera, is really, really critical in living systems.

[39:58](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=2398) So, you know, yeah, everything will, I mean, the reality is everything will change, right. I don't know how many of you are parents. I'm a parent of three. And if that doesn't teach you that everything will change, nothing else will, right. But I think one of the things we want to step back with is we talked about early on that this kind of huge precipice of change, we're already in it, but we can see even more things coming, right. So as a public servant, how do I process an unprecedented amount of data, of information, of options? How do I turn into that information, you know, steward? How do I exercise curiosity? And, you know, of course, again, I'm Google. Technology can absolutely be your ally, and I can give you lots of examples of how that works. But, you know, whether it's technology, whether it's other living system leaders, whether it's people networks, you know, you're not in that alone, right. And in fact, what's really interesting is when you start to confront living systems, what we tend to see is that leaders are able to harness a lot of different tools to actually make their lives easier, you know, faster, you know, simpler than it was before, even though they assumed that it was going to become more complex. And I'm just going to end on kind of four factors. And this is, you know, I think it's really important for us to just end on things that matter to people. And so I'm going to share with you some of the things that as a public servant, I've seen Google do that I think are really interesting about driving that idea of creating living systems, kind of cultures for people to thrive. And again, I realize these are not all, you know, you're not at Google, these aren't, but I really do challenge you, because I actually think everything that I've put on these sheets in one way, shape, or form, I could have done as a public servant, and I plan to do in the future, again, in some degree of implementing it. So the four things that I really want you to think about when you think about people and living system leadership is curiosity, agency, collaboration. And the one thing,

[41:59](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=2519) oh, risk and risk taking, sorry, it was blocked. So those are actually the four principles. So really quickly, I'm going to give you a quick snapshot into like curiosity. I think for those of you, if you are going to learn anything next, or really root yourself in any type of leadership principle, psychological safety is absolutely kind of the standard element that we as leaders have to think about when we want our people to be able to be curious, to be innovative, you know, to have that kind of living system. So if you're not familiar with psychological safety, we have some amazing kind of tools. It is not hard, it is not complex, but I will tell you, it is game-changing to kind of reflect and to have to own whether or not I've always created environments that are psychologically safe. I like to think that I'm a, you know, a great leader and wonderful to work for, but, you know, really looking at psychological safety and how you model that is critical. Again, you know, space, physical, virtual, but this comes down more to not necessarily do you have a cool slide in your office, like the picture shows, but like, are you discouraging, you know, hierarchy? Are you giving space for people to be heard? Are you introducing, you know, play or humanness, right, to the discussion and the interaction? And thank you so much for sharing psychological safety on the right. Yeah, it's really important. It's kind of that safe place for you as an employee, you know, to be able to bring your very best, your insights, your, you know, your feelings and not have anxiety or worry about doing that. And if you think about it as an organization, like that's what we pay for, right? Like, yes, there's your experience, but you have like an experience as a person, right, as a human being, and we want you to bring all of that, you know, especially to something like public service where we're really trying to, you know, do critically important things for the country, for our local communities. You know, you really want the best thinking and the best of your staff in that, you know, and then finally you'll see things like, you know, treating a question, being able to question the status quo, you know, sharing

[44:04](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=2644) ideas, promoting transparency. It was really interesting as an aside, I can't say who, but I'm working on a cultural transformation with a particular military branch and they were telling me all about how psychologically safe it was. And yet when I went down and kind of talked to folks, you know, they said, oh yeah, anything that we send up that is an opinion is then sanitized by our leaders and then sent up, right? So I was like, that's not exactly psychological safety. So, you know, sometimes we can think we do this and we can think we have these ideals, but we really have to step back and look at the individual ways we work, right? Those tactical ways that our culture comes alive to help us understand if we're really creating that. Now, the second one is agency and really if you think about, you know, people, what really drives them and what really incentivizes people is three things. A time... Mastery and Purpose. Agency is a little bit of a mix of some interesting elements of that.

[45:08](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=2708) Agency is really, remember again, I deserve better, that kind of great resignation. I want to be in an environment. Agency is about being able to be your whole self, being able to explore, being able to be curious, being able to engage with others, being able to be active. Sometimes that comes in with autonomy, the idea of being able to work where I need to work to get something done, or mastery, being recognized as having expertise and being respected for that, or purpose, being able to feel like what I do matters. Collaboration. This is probably one of the biggest elements of living systems leadership, and that is living systems leaders really have to functionally create space for collaboration. Not only just safe space from a psychological safety standpoint, but actually mix it up. What are ways, whether it's insights from customers, from outsiders, from experts from other countries, or even crowdsourcing or getting common ideas, but this idea of you can't be curious if you're not constantly opening yourself to collaboration, to new insights, et cetera. The final one is risk-taking. I love that so many of you called out earlier on when we were thinking about those living systems principles, that risk-taking was actually one of either the things you were good at or the things that you were challenged by. I think what's really interesting when I think about risk-taking is, for example, the first example on the screen, what we call g-thanks. When I was a public servant, most of my recognition, validation, formal reviews, they were all very formal and hierarchical.

[46:51](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=2811) They were from a manager, they were above me, if you will. One of the things that I've seen done at Google, which actually is really powerful, is peer-based appreciation. Being able to actually recognize like, hey, Alexis really helped me out on that, or Kate was amazing, she did this, and actually not have to let validation or recognition or creating space for something only be something that a hierarchical leader or manager can do. It's really important to think about how might we actually spread, and that's a little bit of like that autonomy or that empowerment of others in creating space. Even peer recognition is a great place to start. One of the last ones I'll draw your attention to, there's a lot here, is it's not about instant perfection. Living system leadership and the foundation of it is about being curious, and not every element of curiosity is what you're going to want to act on. Not every piece of information or every way of working is going to be right for you, but really putting yourself in that space to be curious, to allow there to be space for imperfection as you explore is really, really important. Finally, we are coming to the end. Thank you all so much. I hope this was helpful. I'm going to open it up for conversation and ask you all to maybe suggest some other parts that we should think about when we think about living system leadership, or where you might see challenges with this. I wanted to highlight maybe if you were someone who wanted to reflect on how this might look like for you, here are five different things post this training that you could think about. Number one, how do you make space for curiosity? Number two, how do you empower yourself to become more of an information leader, an information steward? Specifically reflecting on for you and your work, and then ultimately really asking if I'm leading change, if I'm leading to something,

[48:56](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=2936) what does good evolution of my work, of my organization look like? Only you can answer these questions for you. The point of living systems leadership is that you ask them, is that you're curious and that you're willing to take the time to reflect on them and make space for them and make space for others insights. Then the fifth that I put, just because I think it's foundational, is psychological safety. My hope in what I do is that if there's any way that we can help you on this journey, whether that is with additional training like we're sharing today, helping you tackle a challenge or opportunity that has taught us a lot about living system leadership, or showing you how different groups use technology, the point is that we're really here to be an ally to you all. I will stop with that. I would love to know, was this helpful? Push back on it. Tell me what resonated with you. You're really the experts. I'm just telling you what I've seen from watching a lot of you from afar over the last two years.

**Unknown speaker**

[49:58](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=2998) Thanks, Alexis. Feel free to just jump in or turn on your camera as we have a bit more of a closing discussion with Alexis. Jennifer, yeah. Let's see. That was a really interesting question.

**Alexis Bonnell**

[50:19](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=3019) Living system leadership and time limit grant funding. Yes. Interesting. Jennifer, I have a lot to say on this area because my last gig before leaving was doing a lot of grant funding for innovators and things like that. There are definitely a lot of different tools that we used in a couple of different ways. One, to help actually limit time poverty on grantees and others. Second was actually just how we sourced those and a couple other parameters. Feel free to use my email, Bonnell at Google, and I will tell you, and we can go into this more specifically because I think it's a really rich individual topic. If you have thoughts, I would love to see those or hear those as well. Let's see. Frank, you totally touched on a really important part of living system leadership, and I'm going to amend it thanks to your note, and that is being able to say no and what you have bandwidth and time for right now. One of the really interesting things at Google is when we started, you have your job, and then you have what you call your 20%, and your manager is supposed to be really specific about giving you 20% of your bandwidth in order to actually be curious, to work on something new or different. I thought, yeah, it's going to end up being 120% because that's how these things go. I think what was interesting about that approach was being able to say, all right, I can do that, but this thing you're asking me to do takes away from that 20% or is going to put me into this. What do you want me to do? Trade-offs. What we see is a lot of that psychological safety discussion might tactically come out with someone being able to have that type of conversation with their manager, and sometimes that means that they say, no, I can't do that right now, or unless you make the time or bandwidth or space for me to. It's a really important point. Thank you for that.

**Unknown speaker**

[52:21](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=3141) Feel free to jump in verbally. I'm sure you all are tired of hearing Alexis's voice. Any thoughts on your end, Nicole, in California? I can see you with your fantastic headphones.

**Audience**

[52:32](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=3152) Yeah, those are awesome. Oh, thanks. No, I'm just really enjoying the conversation and listening to all of this great advice. It's kind of new in concept, I think, for some of us over here. I've been with the state for a long time, and just that kind of like the whole 20% and all that, that is not something I've ever encountered. It feels like it would have instantly become 150% somehow, right, of your day.

**Alexis Bonnell**

[52:59](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=3179) But I think what's really interesting, especially for those of you all who are leading in places like DMV or others that have really long set histories, long set processes, things that are there for really good reason, that can feel like a really hard place to say, well, where do you bring in a living systems mindset, right? And I think one of the things that we've seen in organizations like that are a few. One is actually that just starting with a little bit of that exercising scenario, like what if this or what if that, and making, in our reimagining the DMV in another state, one of the things that we started with was just an hour conversation once a month that was both positive and negative scenario play, right? And we're seeing a lot of that scenario play, right? And it was really interesting about, we used a practice that we called Battle Dome, but it was really interesting to see kind of what started to kind of come out and what was possible. And it wasn't necessarily rapid change the next day, right? But it was like little teeny evolutionary things. And sometimes living systems leadership is absolutely about evolution, not revolution. So you can do it. You're going to be my next story, DMV of California.

[54:15](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=3255) I'm coming back. I'm going to get my license in a year and see what y'all are doing.

**Audience**

[54:20](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=3260) Hi, this is Bertha. I wanted to make a comment. Please. So, you know, I think that in, and our best selves and ultimately we all want these things. We want, you know, psychological safety. We want comfort in ambiguity. We want transparency, et cetera, all of the, you know, fine things. But then we have, you know, a hierarchy in our organizations and there are metrics at the different levels of the hierarchy. And the metrics are going to usually, you know, take priority over these other elements. And sometimes they are in direct conflict, you know, for example, the 20% of your time should be allocated for curiosity. Well, in my organization, they specify you get four hours of time per week that is non-billable. And, you know, people have protested against that and, you know, but essentially that's part of government becoming proactive instead of reactive and that's being able to bill for services delivered and they want to bill for them. So, you know, things like that are really challenging to overcome.

**Alexis Bonnell**

[55:54](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=3354) You are, you are so spot on Bertha. And I think one of the things that I love about what you're raising is the fact that, you know, living systems thinking has to meet the reality where it is. Right. And so, you know, one of the things, for example, that we saw, it was kind of interesting with one of our clients that was in a similar position is one of the questions with leadership is, was, do we have to adapt or change or adopt new metrics, right. That reflects something different. So as an example, I used to support a lot of different groups that had call centers, right. And like the call center metric was like, get the person off the phone as fast as possible, right. Like that was a call center metric. And it was really interesting because the team stepped back and said, well, if we instead wanted to say like, how do we help the most people be successful, right. Or have the most, like the greatest experience using a blend of technology and whatever, like how would the metrics look different? And so, you know, total respect, it is not an easy solution, you know, where you're starting from, but I do think, and I'm going to actually go back and put more into metrics now, because I think that's a great point.

[57:03](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=3423) But I do think thinking a little bit about, you know, the what and why of metrics and taking that mentality to kind of like the previous, the current and the future. But you have to have leaders that make space for that. And so hopefully we'll get more leaders who are living system leaders that do that. And maybe you'll be one of them.

**Unknown speaker**

[57:24](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=3444) Great. Thanks, Bertha. And I know we are just over time. So, Alexis, anything else you want to share? We want to thank you so much for joining and giving this fantastic presentation.

**Alexis Bonnell**

[57:36](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=3456) The only thing I have to share is like, God bless public servants. I know and appreciate and love so much what you do. And I know you're why this country and my community works. And I'm planning on coming back one day. So keep it up. Don't despair. We love you. You're appreciated. And if you can get a little bit of living system leader in there, congratulations.

**Unknown speaker**

[57:58](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=3478) Fantastic. Thank you all so much. We'll follow up with a survey and some of these resources tomorrow. And we really look forward to getting all of your feedback so we can improve and evolve and get curious as we move into the future. Alexis, thanks so much. And thanks to everyone who contributed.

**Alexis Bonnell**

[58:14](https://youtu.be/3ej2Gi3dYsw?t=3494) Thanks so much, y'all.

* * *

Original page: https://innovate-us.org/what-now-how-the-role-of-public-servant-leader · Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/), as stated on innovate-us.org
